10-Week module for soas university of london

I’m designing a (one off) 10 week module for @soasuni anthropology undergrads (which I’ll teach). It’ll explore the relation between humans and non-humans/the environment in different social, political and ecological contexts. How do different groups define being human? Why are some people more affected by ecological destruction than others? Why do some humans socialise with plants while others laugh at the idea? Currently inspired by Robin Wall Kimmerer and Vandana Shiva@redguardianesdesemillas and @seed_themovie.

Email me (florahastings3@gmail.com) if you want to find our more about the course or would be interested in hosting a similar course at an educational institution or university.

Upcoming nature immersion workshop!

See more info and buy tickets here.

Permaculture DESIGN course at yakunina, Ecuador

(traducción en español a continuación) I recently returned from a permaculture design course at Yakunina, in the Choco Andino, where we were taught how to design permacultural food and living systems. The Choco Andino is a protected rainforest biosphere in Northern Ecuador (see pictures of the course here). Yakunina is a permacultural farm, and Pauline and Miguel who run it have spent over a decade creating clean water systems, teaching permaculture and mobilising groups in el choco to restore the regions ecology. 

Recently the choco won a vote against further mining in the region, which happened shortly before there was a national referendum that led to the blocking of oil drilling in the Yasuni region of the Amazon. Following tireless activism and campaigning from environmental groups in the country, 68% voted against further drilling in Yasuni while mining was also restricted in the Choco region. Meanwhile while in the UK – Rishi Sunak grants 100 new licenses to oil and gas production in the North Sea without any public consultation. 

Permaculture can be broken down into ‘permanent culture/ agriculture’ and is a system which emerged in the 1970s to propose ways of creating sustainable food and social systems. Permaculture draws from pre-existing agro ecological traditions, many of which developed in Latin America (also known as Abya Yala) over the past 8,000 years. During the course, we learnt from Andean and Incan agricultural traditions as a means to design ecological food structures – from the camellones (Waru Waru in Quechua/ sistemas hidráulicos) to terraces made of cangahua rock which harvested water through level curves in the landscape, an Incan technique. 

Core principles of permaculture include: restoring a landscape through food growing as opposed to depleting it (the opposite of conventional agriculture), integrate food systems into the local ecosystem through mimicking the designs and cycles of the ecosystem around you (such as a creating food forest) and maintaining energy within one’s land through syntropic agriculture (creating systems which build up energy instead of deplete it and rely on external energy sources). The principles and systems of permaculture can be applied to any ecosystem, while many of its inspirations were developed in the tropic regions, owing to the rich tradition of food forests in the Amazon and the tropics more broadly (where many globalised crops were domesticated: rice, potato, sweet potato, cocoa, peanut, rubber, tobacco, cotton, oil palm, coconut, sugarcane, coffee, banana, pineapple, mango, and papaya etc). 

There are many values woven into permaculture that are harder to quantify: the invitation to continue rituals and acts of care that attend to nature (such as the four Raymi festivals celebrated by many Andean indigenous groups in Ecuador), the encouragement of human humility before nature and the need for patient observation of how natural systems work in order to be able to imitate and learn from them, and as Paulina said, the need to create a ‘new culture of water’ whereby we do not watch clean water to die dirty each day by allowing it to pass through contaminating mediums. Permaculture design inspires us to design buildings and landscapes which follow the curves and patterns of nature, putting plants on roofs, making vegetable beds that curve with the topography of the land, allowing for the uneven effect of bioconstruction (that we now often associated with pre-industrial buildings). 

In the course, we were joined by climate activists who had spent years preserving the choco, such as Jaime and Mimi who have guarded 600 species of fruit on their farm, to Arariwa who, over in Cuenca, has been fighting with many others in Kimsakocha, protecting Andean lagoons against the pollution of gold mining in the region. Article pasted below. 

This trip was made possible by an ESRC grant and will be used to understand permaculture as its developing in urban gardens in Barcelona, often shaped by migrants from Latin America/ Abya Yala. Yakunina also accept volunteers (ideally Spanish speaking but not obligatory).

https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/democraciaabierta/ecuador-water-defenders-gold-mining-river-pollution/

Some of Yakunina’s permacultural lessons..

1)To design water systems within a given topography, we learnt how to use accessible technology, like a Water Level (a hose filled with water with wooden sticks), instead of expensive computer programmes and drones. This allowed us to measure the level curves of a landscape and learn how to harvest and drain water. Trees, plants and shaped soil help massively to prevent soil erosion and help store water in the ground, crucial when climate heating causes increased water evaporation after rain. 

2)We learnt how to collect colonies of micro organisms (such as mycelium webs) from the forest and reproduce them, creating fertiliser that will speed up the creation of healthy soil, nutrient cycling and the decomposition of plant matter. 

3)We visited a finca which grew over 600 species of local fruit, all growing in the soil within a healthy food forest – crucial when the globe relies on only 15 crops for 90% of our energy intake. The mass commercialisation of a few crops has led to the extinction of millions of plant species that may have been genetically resilient to the climate extremes and pathogens which we now face. 

4)We learnt how to build a wall using natural materials (clay, rocks, sand, hay) gathered from the surrounding landscape – and which is cheap to do if you find volunteers to help you and cuts out the need for construction materials that rely on long supply chains. Minga is quechuan word which some andean communities use to designate communal agricultural work, and often Mingas were used to communally build houses. 

5)We learnt how to purify water through the use of carbon filters and vermifilters – converting grey (bathroom and kitchen) and black (toilet) water into clean water that was filtered through worms and then papyrus plants, turning toilet waste into water that fed a diverse ecosystem in the shape of a beautiful lagoon. Pauline and Miguel taught us about the damage to ecosystems caused by the amount of grey water (soap, shower, sink) that goes directly into the rivers without being treated, killing local ecosystems and polluting the water. In the UK, water companies have been dumping raw sewage into rivers illegally. In 2022 in the UK, water firms discharged raw sewage 300,000 times last year,

6)We learnt how to slowly replenish poor soil through mimicking the growth succession of wooded ecosystems: first planting low, annual plants and eventually onto tree species that mimic the long standing species of a climax community (complex, healthy ecosystem). The finca of Yakunina itself used to be a monoculture of palmitos, and Miguel and Paulina have been slowly restoring the land to merge with the wider ecosystem of the choco – bringing monkeys, frogs, toads, snakes, spiders, insects, birds (and countless other species) closer and closer to their land. In the choco andino, which was declared a protected biosphere by UNESCO in 2018 (following mobilisation by local activists), there are 700 species of birds, 140 amphibians and 40 kinds of reptiles. 

7)We learnt how to forage and prepare PANCS (healthy non-conventional plants), as a core part of transitioning to permaculture food systems is shifting from our dietary reliance on annual crops to perennial crops that flourish in abundant, shady forest systems. 

8)We were told about the manifold impacts of agribusiness in Ecuador: from exploitation of workers, cancer and mental health problems caused by breathing in pesticides, the permanent pollution of water through mining (by the insertion of metal particles into the water system), the assassination of activists who try and confront the water pollution in the country. 

9)we learnt how to break the carbon dioxide cycle through burning wood and burying it into the soil where it the carbon will remain stored and become energy course of soil microbes (and not escape back into the atmosphere as carbon dioxide). 

To learn more about these topics, listen to Radio Semillas, a podcast run by Gaurdianas De Semillas (which Yakunina form a part of).

Tranducion a Español:

Acabo de regresar de un curso de diseño de permacultura en Yakunina, en el Chocó Andino, una biosfera de selva tropical protegida en el norte de Ecuador. Yakunina es una granja permacultural, y Pauline y Miguel, quienes la dirigen, han pasado más de una década creando sistemas de agua limpia, enseñando permacultura y movilizando grupos en el Choco region para restaurar la ecología del area.

Recientemente, el Choco ganó una votación en contra del crecimiento de minería en la región, lo que ocurrió poco antes de que hubiera un referéndum nacional que condujo al bloqueo de la extracción de petróleo en la región de Yasuní en el Amazonas. Luego del incansable activismo y campaña de los grupos ambientalistas del país, el 68% votó en contra de nuevas perforaciones en Yasuní, mientras que la minería también fue restringida en la región del Chocó. Mientras tanto, en el Reino Unido, Rishi Sunak concede 100 nuevas licencias para la producción de petróleo y gas en el Mar del Norte sin ninguna consulta pública.

La permacultura se puede dividir en “cultura/agricultura permanente” y es un sistema que surgió en la década de 1970 para proponer formas de crear sistemas alimentarios y sociales sostenibles. La permacultura se basa en tradiciones agroecológicas preexistentes, muchas de las cuales se desarrollaron en América Latina (también conocida como Abya Yala) durante los últimos 8.000 años. Durante el curso, aprendimos de las tradiciones agrícolas andinas e incas como medios para diseñar estructuras alimentarias ecológicas, desde los camellones (Waru Waru en quechua/sistemas hidráulicos) hasta terrazas hechas de roca cangahua que recolectaban agua a través de curvas de nivel en el paisaje, un Técnica inca.

Los principios básicos de la permacultura incluyen: restaurar un paisaje mediante el cultivo de alimentos en lugar de agotarlo (lo opuesto a la agricultura convencional), integrar los sistemas alimentarios en el ecosistema local imitando los diseños y ciclos del ecosistema que lo rodea (como la creación de un bosque de alimentos). ) y mantener la energía dentro de la propia tierra a través de la agricultura sintrópica (creando sistemas que acumulan energía en lugar de agotarla y dependen de fuentes de energía externas). Los principios y sistemas de la permacultura se pueden aplicar a cualquier ecosistema, mientras que muchas de sus inspiraciones se desarrollaron en las regiones tropicales, debido a la rica tradición de los bosques alimentarios en el Amazonas y en los trópicos en general (donde se domesticaron muchos cultivos globalizados: el arroz). , papa, batata, cacao, maní, caucho, tabaco, algodón, palma aceitera, coco, caña de azúcar, café, plátano, piña, mango y papaya, etc.).

Hay muchos valores entretejidos en la permacultura que son más difíciles de cuantificar: la invitación a continuar con rituales y actos de cuidado que atiendan a la naturaleza (como los cuatro festivales Raymi celebrados por muchos grupos indígenas andinos en Ecuador), el estímulo a la humildad humana ante la naturaleza y la necesidad de observar pacientemente cómo funcionan los sistemas naturales para poder imitarlos y aprender de ellos, y como dijo Paulina, la necesidad de crear una ‘nueva cultura del agua’ mediante la cual no veamos que el agua limpia muera sucia cada vez. día dejándolo pasar a través de medios contaminantes. El diseño de permacultura nos inspira a diseñar edificios y paisajes que siguen las curvas y patrones de la naturaleza, colocando plantas en los techos, creando huertos que se curvan con la topografía del terreno, permitiendo el efecto desigual de la bioconstrucción (que ahora asociamos a menudo con la prehistoria). -edificios industriales).

En el curso nos acompañaron activistas climáticos que llevaban años preservando el choco, como Jaime y Mimi que han custodiado 600 especies de frutas en su finca, hasta Arariwa que, en Cuenca, ha estado peleando con muchos otros en Kimsakocha. , protegiendo las lagunas andinas contra la contaminación de la minería aurífera en la región. Artículo pegado a continuación.

Este viaje fue posible gracias a una subvención de ESRC y se utilizará para comprender la permacultura como su desarrollo en los jardines urbanos de Barcelona, ​​a menudo moldeados por inmigrantes de América Latina/Abya Yala. Yakunina aceptan voluntarios tambien. 

https://www.opendemocracy.net/democraciaabierta/ecuador-water-defenders-gold-mining-river-pollution/

Algunas de las lecciones que tuvimos en orden de las fotos:

1. Para diseñar sistemas de agua dentro de una topografía determinada, aprendimos a utilizar tecnología accesible, como un nivel de agua (una manguera llena de agua con palos de madera), en lugar de costosos programas de computadora y drones. Esto nos permitió medir las curvas de nivel de un paisaje y aprender a recolectar y drenar agua. Los árboles, las plantas y el suelo moldeado ayudan enormemente a prevenir la erosión del suelo y ayudan a almacenar agua en el suelo, algo crucial cuando el calentamiento climático provoca una mayor evaporación del agua después de la lluvia.

2) Aprendimos cómo recolectar colonias de microorganismos (como redes de micelio) del bosque y reproducirlas, creando fertilizantes que acelerarán la creación de suelo saludable, el ciclo de nutrientes y la descomposición de la materia vegetal.

3) Visitamos una finca que cultivaba más de 600 especies de frutas locales, todas creciendo en el suelo dentro de un bosque de alimentos saludables – crucial cuando el mundo depende de sólo 15 cultivos para el 90% de nuestra ingesta de energía. La comercialización masiva de unos pocos cultivos ha llevado a la extinción de millones de especies de plantas que pueden haber sido genéticamente resistentes a los extremos climáticos y a los patógenos a los que nos enfrentamos ahora.

4) Aprendimos cómo construir un muro utilizando materiales naturales (arcilla, rocas, arena, heno) recolectados del paisaje circundante, y lo cual es barato de hacer si encuentras voluntarios que te ayuden y eliminas la necesidad de materiales de construcción que dependen de en largas cadenas de suministro. Minga es una palabra quechua que algunas comunidades andinas utilizan para designar el trabajo agrícola comunal y, a menudo, las mingas se utilizaban para construir casas comunitarias.

5) Aprendimos cómo purificar el agua mediante el uso de filtros de carbón y vermifiltros, convirtiendo el agua gris (baño y cocina) y negra (inodoro) en agua limpia que se filtraba a través de lombrices y luego plantas de papiro, convirtiendo los desechos del inodoro en agua que alimentaba un ecosistema diverso en forma de una hermosa laguna. Pauline y Miguel nos enseñaron sobre el daño a los ecosistemas causado por la cantidad de aguas grises (jabón, ducha, lavabo) que van directamente a los ríos sin ser tratadas, matando los ecosistemas locales y contaminando el agua. En el Reino Unido, las compañías de agua han estado vertiendo ilegalmente aguas residuales sin tratar en los ríos. En 2022, en el Reino Unido, las empresas de agua descargaron aguas residuales sin tratar 300.000 veces el año pasado.

6) Aprendimos cómo reponer lentamente los suelos pobres imitando la sucesión de crecimiento de los ecosistemas boscosos: primero plantando plantas anuales bajas y, finalmente, especies de árboles que imitan las especies de larga data de una comunidad clímax (ecosistema complejo y saludable). La propia finca de Yakunina solía ser un monocultivo de palmitos, y Miguel y Paulina han estado restaurando lentamente la tierra para fusionarla con el ecosistema más amplio del choco – trayendo monos, ranas, sapos, serpientes, arañas, insectos, pájaros (e innumerables otras especies) cada vez más cerca de su tierra. En el choco andino, declarado biosfera protegida por la UNESCO en 2018 (tras la movilización de activistas locales), habitan 700 especies de aves, 140 anfibios y 40 clases de reptiles.

7) Aprendimos cómo buscar y preparar PANCS (plantas no convencionales saludables), ya que una parte central de la transición a sistemas alimentarios de permacultura es pasar de nuestra dependencia dietética de cultivos anuales a cultivos perennes que florecen en sistemas forestales abundantes y sombreados.

8) Nos hablaron de los múltiples impactos del agronegocio en Ecuador: desde la explotación de los trabajadores, el cáncer y los problemas de salud mental causados ​​por la inhalación de pesticidas, la contaminación permanente del agua a través de la minería (por la inserción de partículas metálicas en el sistema de agua), el asesinato de activistas que intentan enfrentar la contaminación del agua en el país.

9) aprendimos cómo romper el ciclo del dióxido de carbono quemando madera y enterrándola en el suelo, donde el carbono permanecerá almacenado y se convertirá en energía para los microbios del suelo (y no escapará de regreso a la atmósfera como dióxido de carbono).

Para conocer más sobre estos temas, escuche Radio Semillas, un podcast dirigido por Gaurdianas De Semillas (del cual Yakunina forma parte).

Nature immersion workshop: non-institutional

I guided an immersive workshop in Hampstead Heath on the 27th of August. Through touch, smell, play, imagination and language, we collectively explored multiple questions. How can we navigate through using lichen on a tree and learn to sense the micro-climates around us? How do London’s infrastructure shape how we know the natural world? How have our own pasts been shaped by the non-human world? How do different cultures define nature? The overarching idea of this workshop was to provide a space where participants could deepen and complicate their relation with the wider natural world.

The first half of the workshop guided participants to sense the forest, both learning how to figure out your direction using trees and lichen, as well as sense the age and micro-climates of the woods. The second part of the workshop involved a creative and contemplative process. Through fictional narrative, creative writing and probing questions, participants explored how their own lives have been shaped by the ecological webs around them. Poems, drawings and auto-biographical fragments unravelled beneath a canopy of birch trees.

The workshop aimed to bring anthropological techniques into the space. A core part of anthropology is exploring how foundational terms like ‘nature’ have radically different cross-cultural meanings. We unpacked the meaning of ‘nature’ in our own lives and cross culturally, becoming more aware of its shifting meanings through time and place and how humans have changed the way they narrativise their placement within a multi-species world. As with my previous immersive workshops, I draw on an ecological pedagogy that emphasises the senses, memory and emotion as indispensable mediums through which to learn more about ecology, nature and non-human worlds.

At the end of the workshop, participants were sent a collection of resources for more independent exploration, as well as citations of the authors who shaped the various activities.

The guided narrative framing of the second activity was inspired by Jo Krishnakumar who led an incredible workshop titled ‘Kicking Down Doors: Closets, Disciplines and the University’, as part of the Festival of Decolonial Learning for Westminster University (permission was granted to adapt the frame). See more of their work here.

If you can think of any institutions or workplaces that might be interested in hosting one of these workshops, please email me! florahastings3@gmail.com. I aim to run these workshops through 2024, including winter sessions!

^ photo by James Kite

Ethnographic Immersion in hampstead heath – Sustainability summer school

As part of SOAS’ ‘Anthropology of Sustainability: Global Challenges and Alternative Futures’ summer school, I was invited by Dr. Saad Quasem to take students on an immersive walk into Hampstead Heath. The walk, building off past workshops I’ve been developing inside and outside the academy, aimed to get students practising ethnographic research methods, and more specifically, to explore how anthropologists are well placed to explore humans’ embeddedness in multi-species environments.

We explored how sensory methodologies allow us to think about ‘sustainability’ (as material structure, discourse and ‘alternative future’) in multi-dimensional ways.

The three sensory activities involved smell, touch and hearing. Some of the questions we explored, following the sensory invitations, included:

How might multi-species infrastructures, such as green corridors in cities, shift how inhabitants relate to non-humans? How might the growth of urban food gardens in many cities provide alternative spaces for humans to form relations with more-than-humans? 

In a world where populations increasingly live in environments that shape the body’s genetic make up / cause inter-generational contamination through pollutants, how might this shape how the human body is defined or humans’ sense of entanglement with their wider material environment?

Some of the more personal topics we discussed included:

Traditions around touching or not being able to touch aspects of the environment (tea crops, large trees)

How trees relate to ancestry and how we define ancestry

Memories of grandparents’ teachings around nature

The agency of plants

How we relate to ‘nature’ and ‘culture’ differently depending on where we are in the city (and whether this binary is useful)

Another aim of the workshop was to encourage students to become more self-reflexive as to their assumptions or semi-conscious categories they possess around the natural world. Do they feel plants are animate? how do they define ‘the social’? what does kinship mean to them and does it include multiple species? How do we define ‘the human’?

In anthropology, self-reflexivity is crucial if ethnographers want to avoid projecting presumed universal truths onto other groups. Considering the non-linguistic and sensory way in which humans engage with the wider ecological surroundings (and are shaped by them), it might take touch, smell and hearing (etc) in an outside location to become more aware as to one’s deeply held notions.

Ecological pedagogies, inspired by teachers such as Robin Wall Kimmerer, encourage individuals to place themselves, in both an affective, sensory and discursive way, within the wider context of the ecosystem (allowing that the scientific language of ‘ecosystem’ does not reflect the plethora of how humans conceive of the wider environment). Feeling and encountering the interconnection between multiple beings may make this material reality more immediate – and easier to connect to wider anthropological discussions – than text based or more abstract encounters.

Two students mentioned feeling ‘calm’ after the walk/workshop. The benefits of taking learning out of the academy and outside, and distancing learning from a primarily text/language based format, are multiple. I also sense (and drawing from multiple students’ comments to me) that the context of a park / the outdoors might be less intimating for many students than classrooms in a university building, allowing for more free flowing discussion (and involvement of students who might not normally talk in class).

Jewish Ecologies: Immersive WORKSHOP in Berlin

This June 2023, Daniel Voskoboynik and I were invited to lead a parsha session and workshop for Ze Kollel (a partnership between Hillel Deutschland and Oy Vey Amsterdam) in Berlin. Parsha means ‘portion’ in Hebrew, and refers to the Jewish practice of reading a portion of the Torah each week. Daniel is an ecologist, writer and musician. These workshops built upon past collaborations with Lievnath Faber and Margot Fuentes Kratter, with whom we organized a series of workshops related to shmita (see below) over the course of four days in Barcelona, August 2022.

For the two workshops we guided, we applied ecological and sensorial pedagogies, some of which I have been developing at SOAS university.

As Daniel phrased it, we can define ecology as ‘valuing and attending to the connections that sustain life and all the lives that are moving through us, whether that be microorganisms, plants, people we meet or the air we inhale and exhale’. How we co-exist with the more-than-human world is never beyond us, ‘out there’, but forms part of our daily habits, the food we eat and the ecologies which we exist with in urban or rural environments. 

In Judaism, the balance between humans, plants, animals and the land has been a concern for millennia, such as within the biblical commandment to let all agricultural land lie fallow every 7th year and renounce ownership of one’s crops. This commandment is encased within the festival ‘shmita’, meaning ‘release’ in Hebrew. We infused the questions we asked in the session with the ecological principles of shmita, explored in depth in the Palestinian Talmud. Our questions guided the group to consider human relations to the more-than-human, conceptions of land (wilderness vs. domestication) and sharing land resources with ethnic/religious groups (whether in the context of the ancient land of Canaan to the present day Israel-Palestine conflict). 

The importance of inter-cultural Torah and Talmud in a time of ecological crisis and violent occupation of shared land is essential. We drew on the teachings of many indigenous thinkers from the Americas, such as the indigenous Brazilian philosopher and activist Aílton Krenak, and Robin Wall Kimmerer, botanist and member of the Potawatomi nation.

In the second workshop we ran, Daniel was granted permission to adapt a portion of the methodology of mapeo del cuerpo-territory (body-territory mapping) to the session. This is a methodology of corporal-territorial protection and exploration elevated by the Colectivo Miradas Criticas. Through this methodology, we aimed to expand our literacy when it comes to mapping the inter-connected dynamics between the body, the self and the landscapes around us.

Finally, we aimed to encourage a more ecological approach to reading and analyzing the Torah/Talmud**. In Judaism, the traditional mode of textual study between two people (or, a ‘chevrusa’, which means friendship in Aramaic) often relies on conversation, usually following a close reading of the text and taking place inside (such as in a Yeshiva). During the chevrusa session, we invited the group to walk around outside in silence, sensorial engaging with the plants and elements in the garden. How might these beings feel their way through space, experience stress or safety where they are? These encounters highlight the limits of human language (and even text) when thinking through phenomena in a deeply ecological/ empathetic mode. 

Some of the themes our participants brought up in the group discussions during the session included: 

> The (im)possibilities of being able to perceive the world from a non-human perspective

> The way language (such as grammar) and also textual practises can shape relations to the more than human world

> How we relate to areas of land such as ‘wilderness’ and its representation in the Torah/ Talmud

> Hierarchies of species as represented in Jewish written/oral Torah 

Ecological pedagogies encourage individuals to place themselves, in both an affective, sensory and discursive way, within the wider context of the ecosystem (allowing that the scientific language of ‘ecosystem’ does not reflect the plethora of how humans conceive of the wider environment). Feeling and encountering the interconnection between multiple beings may make this material reality more immediate than text based or more abstract encounters. These pedagogies can be applied to Jewish textual practices as much as to other cultural/religious contexts. My anthropological learning also shapes this approach, where ‘making the familiar strange and the strange familiar’ enables us to question semi-conscious, assumed ‘truths’ about the world through making us become aware of our deeply held beliefs or ontologies (sense of what is ‘real’/exists in the world) in a self-reflexive manner, such as the meaning of ‘human’. I have also tried to bring sensorial, outdoors learning into SOAS anthropology department by exploring multi-species ethnographic research methodologies in a non-linguistic, sensory setting, preparing students for multi-species encounters ‘in the field’. 

*my framing of Zionism in this document does not represent the views of all those in the session, nor Ze Kollel, Hillel Deutschland or Oy Vey Amsterdam.

**It should be noted that textual study is not the primary or only way in which Jews have or do explore questions about ‘ecology’. There is an exciting movement of (often radical diasporist) Jewish farmers in the States and Europe, applying principles from the texts to their farming practices. Many thinkers within diasporic ‘earth based Judaism’ movements also centralize the (at times sidelined) agro-ecological aspects of the religion, applying them to diasporic settings, such as Miknaf Haaretz. Lastly, we are not stating that Jewish textual study in more traditional forms is within itself ‘un-ecological’, while we are aware that definitions of ‘text’ and ‘language’ are relative. 

***cover photo taken by Daniel in a forest close to Wannsee Lake, Germany.

Immersive walk: thames barrier

With the input of Dr. Saad Quasem, I guided an immersive walk by London’s Thames Barrier. This walk was held as part of SOAS Universities Anthropology and Climate Change module, taught and designed by Dr. Saad Quasem. This module is nestled within the MA programme of ‘Anthropology of Global Futures and Sustainability’. Similarly to an earlier workshop I held in Hampstead Heath for SOAS, the idea of the workshop was to prepare pre-fieldwork anthropology students for multi-sensory ethnographic research. We began by speaking briefly about sensory anthropology, nature-culture ontological dualisms and the push of multi-species anthropology to move beyond this. Students were then invited to follow a written guide (preferably in silence) which invited them to experience the landscape in three sensory ways. Some questions from the guide, which followed instructions to smell, touch, listen and observe various aspects of their surroundings:

How would our relation/kinship to the Thames and the microbial life in our bodies change if urban water infrastructures were different? How do urban infrastructures govern our relation to the more-than-human, and how might anthropologists go about studying this?

In an era where human-shaped landscapes are writing themselves into the human body at an increasing speed, how do we define the ‘human’? How does international human rights law assume an abstract, universal human subject, that does not account for subjective and experienced instances of bodily difference? If you studied workers who suffered from chemical contamination, how could their microbiomes be brought into your ethnographic research?

What are the sounds of luxury, future-oriented urban areas? What sounds are removed and how does this shape our phenomenology experience of urban space and multi-species environments? If you did an ethnographic study of this area, how would sound be incorporated into your methods?

Later as we sat in the pub, we spoke about the Dock workers who used to labour and live by the Royal Docks / Newham, and how their being gentrified out of the area related to infrastructural changes of the Thames (the river being cleaned up since being pronounced biologically dead in 1957, and the construction of luxury flats and the Thames Barrier in 1974). Please contact me if you would like to see the guide (florahastings3@gmail.com).

Dr. Saad Quasem, who convened and taught the module, helped with the design of the workshop. His doctoral research, located in Bangladesh, ‘explored the chars (river islands) on the Brahmaputra River and the subjectivity of Chardwellers given the colonial and post-colonial nation-state’s practices of appraising and appropriating land rather than water’.

Art work under title of post by P J Lee, “The Thames Barrier”.

Jewish-muslim research network

From 2019 to 2020 I was lucky to be one of three co-ordinators of the Jewish-Muslim Research Network. Founded by Adi Bharat and Katharine Halls, the JMRN brings together researchers studying Jews, Muslims, Judaism and Islam in any time period and region. Through book launches, seminars and reading groups we’ve been bringing scholars together to question the ways we understand Jews, Muslims and how both groups relate and interact with one another. Over the past few decades, within the media and popular discourse Jewish and Muslim relations have often been imagined as tense, with the Israeli Occupation or terrorism being the primary angles through which the topic has been discussed. Yet research from anthropology, Jewish studies and Middle East Studies sheds alternate light on such topics, such as through exploring histories of Jewish existence in Muslim majority countries. In my former anthropological research, I found it useful to understand Jewish existence in contemporary Europe through case studies within the Anthropology of Islam, such as comparing Islamophobic and anti-Semitic discourses and movements.

Link to the website here. Links to our past events here (see events from 2019-21 below).

outdoors anthropology workshop for soas

About

I held an immersive outdoors workshop for SOAS University of London anthropology department, as part of SASA (SOAS Anthropology Student Association). The idea of the workshop was to prepare pre-fieldwork anthropology students for multi-sensory ethnographic research.

We began by speaking briefly about sensory anthropology, nature-culture ontological dualisms and the push of multi-species anthropology to move beyond this. Participants then spent around 30 minutes following the guide in silence, before we rejoined to discuss our experiences for around 20 minutes. 

The written guide aimed to explore ethnographies whereby alternative relations to the natural world and the senses have been explored, with the goal of helping participants feel more equip to conduct anthropological research in a way which engages all the senses and does not reproduce nature/culture ontological dualisms. There were five suggested actions for students to follow, which engaged their senses (touch, taste, smell, feel, sight) . Each sensory ‘invitation’ was woven into explorations of ethnographies focusing on a similar sensory experience or inter-species interaction.

The pedagogic premise of the workshop is that this kind of pre-field sensory training should be done through the senses, as there are a whole range of experiences or inter-species relations which can not be easily, or at all, represented in the classroom through the medium of thought and human language. 

If you would like to hear more about this workshop, or potentially want me to run one for your anthropology department, please get in touch: florahastings3@gmail.com

Reflections on the workshop from participants

Reflections on and a photo of the workshop by Zixuan Song, an MA student in SOAS’ anthropology department (shared with her consent):

“The last task of the activity was to find mushrooms, and my first association was Anna Tsing’s The Mushroom at the End of the World. Although I searched for them for a long time without finding them, I saw so many creatures that I didn’t think would ever appear in the forest. The leaves on the ground were more than just a “pile or cover”, they were the ecological chain itself.

When looking up at the trees, I noticed that there were green trees, dry trees and trees that were about to sprout. In the forest, I prefer to believe that the concept of seasons is for people, time and temperature are perceived in a different way here, and that in the forest there may not be four seasons, but all seasons”

Films by Yueh-Chou Ho, learn about his anthropological research here. These clips were taken on route to the silent part of the workshop, where we followed a sensory guide for half an hour (photographed below).

Drawings from Lucian Wu, a BA student of Social Sciences at Kings College University. Lucian reflected:

‘Thanks for today’s walk, it was really peaceful and needed. Here are some sketches I rushed through whilst trying to take in the nature…I think drawing non-human life feels quite social, cause it’s like a labor of love just as much as drawing faces and animals is’

Ongoing Ethnographic rEsearch Angles – “españa vaciada”

As part of my ethnographic research, I recently visited a hamlet (anonymised) in Castilla de La Mancha, in an elevated region known as ‘the Sibera of Spain’ for its cold weather. Only 6 people live here, while around 50 years ago, over 100 people did (forming part of a wider rural-urban migration process referred to commonly as La España Vaciada, Emptied Spain). The hamlet used to function through subsistence farming and used little money, relying mostly on trade. The man in photo six used to spend 3 months a year sleeping open air in the communal owned mount (el monte, photographed) to make vegetable carbon (he was the ‘carbonero’), while also hunting hares (liebres) for food and cutting encina trees for firewood (leña) and trading it for vegetables from a neighbouring hamlet who had access to irrigated land.

One aim of my thesis is to understand how the formation of (often illegal re-appropriated) green space in Barcelona draws from modes of sociality, epistemologies (ways of creating knowledge) and relations to nature/culture which stem from the subsistence backgrounds that many of my participants grew up in/ migrated from. Public green spaces are formed by a complex blend of individuals and groups. Beyond rural ex-payeses, many who form part of these zones have migrated from Global South nations ravaged by Spanish/ European (neo)-colonial projects of resource extraction and industrial modernisation, bringing with them knowledge of non-industrial food cultivation and different perceptions of how humans should exist within a mainly non-human planet, and even what it means to be ‘human’.

International womEns’ day – mental health & spirituality

For international women’s day 2022, I was invited to speak on an inter-faith panel, hosted by Associació Arrissalah and taking place in the Civic Centre of Pla d’En boet in Cataloina. We reflected on secularism, intolerance to religious minorities in Spain and what it’s like to be openly religious and a women in the workplace. For Arabic speakers, the event was covered by a Moroccan News channel: 

commissioned by Mozaika Journal

The Berlin in Netflix’s Unorthodox is a multicultural utopia – if only this were the reality. The show’s celebratory depiction of Berlin as a haven for asylum seekers turns the series into uncritical EU propaganda. It is crucial to challenge the series’ two most tantalising myths; that Berlin has entirely reformed from its violent 20th- century nationalism and that the city embraces its many migrants and asylum seekers.

Unorthodox follows the journey of Esty Shapiro as she escapes from the ultra-Orthodox Jewish Satmar community of Crown Heights, New York. Etsy finds her way to Berlin, where her estranged mother lives after also escaping from the community. Across the engrossing four episodes, we watch as Etsy finds romance within a clique of musical Berliners, reconnects with her mother, and dodges her Satmar husband, who’s come to Germany to track her down. Beneath the tense plot twists, we watch Etsy’s inward journey as she finds the parts of herself denied in New York. While Etsy’s life in New York and her escape is based on the memoir of Deborah Feldman, the scenes in Germany are fictional. The show has garnered accolades, such as for its use of Yiddish, and criticism for its negative representation of the Satmar community. 

It was not difficult for Etsy to find belonging in Berlin, and nor for that matter, the other asylum seekers and migrants who she meets. From the lake scene where Etsy wades into the water with the group of hip music students, to the prestigious conservatory which has scholarships for refugees, Berlin oozes an easy and fun-going tolerance which sets up a stark contrast to the fortress-like isolation of Crown Height’s Satmar community.

While watching the laughing faces of (seemingly every) extra in the background and the carnivalesque imagery, I waited for a scene that would give voice to the obvious difficulties faced by minorities in Berlin. Mine and my family’s experiences in the city clamoured in the background. My Jewish grandmother and her parents fled Nazi Berlin in 1939. When my family and I returned to the city, while the conditions are incomparable, our times there were peppered with painful reminders that vestiges of Europe’s violent nationalist and racist ideologies still exist. Our experiences make it easier to see through the two myths which Unorthodox un-critically supports.

Photography Anika Molnar/NETFLIX

In the series, dwelling on Germany’s past is pointless because apparently, the country has moved on from its former violent ideologies. Get on with your life. This position is crystallised in the series’ lake scene. A few hours before Etsy wades into the waters of Wannsee lake and removes her sheitel (wig), signalling her newly claimed freedom, our protagonist had approached a group of music students on the street in Berlin and boldly asked them if she could accompany them to the lake. As she stands on the shore, Robert (her future lover), points to a villa on the water’s edge and explains how ‘the conference where the Nazis decided to kill the Jews in concentration camps took place in 1942’ there. ‘And you swim in this lake?’ Etsy asks, visibly disturbed. Robert shrugs, ‘Well, the lake is just a lake’. As Robert dives into the crystalline waters, Etsy turns to see a stranger lifting his smiling baby up. ‘Deutschland’ is ominously blazoned in ink across his toned back. This image, the only hint towards any existence of the far-right in Germany, is quickly drowned out in the waters of the lake which Etsy wades into a few moments after. Robert’s attitude to the past is set up as the correct one by the other references to memory scattered through the show. The ‘now it’s just a lake’ position constantly wins, as the main characters demonstrate that dwelling on the past is needless. 

Robert, amongst other characters, represents the attitude that Germany, through educational and commemorative efforts, has cut ties with the dominant political ideologies of the 20th century. This attitude reflects broader conceptions, within and outside Germany, that through museums, educational efforts, and reparations, many European nations have been able to reform from their fascistic nationalist pasts. Like Austria, since the 1960s, the German government made many laudable efforts to build a social memory around the Holocaust that accounted for the genocidal violence. Jews were granted reparations through the right of return laws, monuments, and museums to educate Germans about the horrors of the Holocaust and the state’s (still ongoing) persecution of War criminals hammers in the notion that justice lay after 1945. 

Yet the past is messy in Germany, as it is anywhere. There is no unified understanding of recent history or how the present is informed by 20th-century events. Neo-Nazis have sprouted up across Germany since the 1950s, many commemorating Hitler through salutes and genocidal slogans. Within the German parliament, far-right parties such as the ADF bear more complex relations to the past, with one of its founders, Björn Höcke, critically calling the Holocaust memorial ‘a monument of shame’. Ideologies that informed Nazi Germany, from ethnic nationalism to Aerian genetic supremacy, will find their way in different forms in groups today and may find new victims, such as asylum seekers from across the Middle East.

Seen through this less rose-tinted lens, Etsy’s surprise when Robert coolly stated, ‘it’s just a lake’ is not the incorrect position. Lakes, squares and buildings which bore witness to key moments of past political regimes will be reclaimed and interpreted ceaselessly by different groups. To carry with you a weariness of the past can be a form of self-protection. In October of 2020, it was hard not to feel vulnerable when my family and I walked into Tiergarten park in Berlin and realised that we had entered an anti-Covid protest which led to the storming of the Reichstag and included 3,000 members of the far-right. It was surreal to be surrounded by the flags of the pre-1918 German Empire that are often associated with Neo-Nazism. A few years before, my brother was struck in the back of the head in Görlitzer Park in 2015. He had been running through it, and his star of David came out. To stroll around Germany with a sense that the past is over and the nation is a haven of liberal tolerance would make us oblivious to the growth of far-right extremism in the country and the historically loaded spaces where violence may rear its head. 

Sometimes feeling haunted by the ghosts of the past is a form of protection in the present. It is not something to be belittled, as often happened in the series. Europe, and its many nations, have not simply ‘moved on’ from the past, and to state so encourages an attitude of complacency that sees the work of social reformation as over.

Demonstrators in front of Berlin’s Brandenburg Gate, on Saturday. Many waved the historic black-white-red ‘Reichsflag’, others displayed extremist symbols or wore clothing favoured by neo-Nazis. Photograph: Clemens Bilan/EPA

The second myth within Unorthodox is its celebration of Berlin as a haven for its many asylum seekers, refugees and migrants. The series becomes more than a story about Etsy finding herself within Berlin through telling the tale of multiple minorities finding acceptance in Germany. Within Etsy’s small gaggle of friends, Ahmed had moved from Nigeria, Yael has migrated from Israel and Dasia is of Yemeni heritage. Etsy’s mother kisses her girlfriend on the street, relaxed and un-self-conscious. Ahmed suggests that he came to Berlin’s music school because ‘imagine being a gay kid in Nigeria’. Etsy’s own acceptance is rapid. The things she felt shame for in the Satmar community become instantly cool in Berlin, from her shaved head to her singing loudly in Yiddish in her conservatory audition. A binary is set up in the show: there is bad, here is good. The ‘there’ is often associated with non-Western countries or minority religious groups, while the ‘here’ is associated with a progressive, European culture of multicultural acceptance.

Photography Anika Molnar/NETFLIX

This positive representation of Berlin draws from a range of popularly held narratives about Germany and Europe. Germany is often celebrated for its efforts of reformation following 20th century Nazism, with its status as having accepted the most migrants in the refugee crisis of 2015 further evidence that the nation accommodates ethnic and religious diversity. Yet a more European-wide idea weaves itself through the series. White Europeans have historically defined Europe in civilisational terms, deemed as more progressive and liberal than supposedly less “enlightened” nations. Since the 15th century, this imagined superiority has justified grotesque violence against supposed ‘backwards’, non-white or non-Christian groups through imperialism and colonialism. Today, an un-questioning sense of Euro-American progressiveness, tolerance, and in many cases, racial superiority, still exists in multiple forms that bear both similarities and differences to pre-21st century ideas. It is no surprise that it took so long before contemporary acts of white supremacist violence were perceived as ‘terrorism’ in Europe. Terrorism was something that happened over there, not here. 

There is much to celebrate about Germany, and especially Berlin. The active and long-established LGBTQI+ communities in the city makes it a far safer place for many to be openly queer or transgender. However, discrimination against non-white asylum seekers, migrants, and LGBTQI+ persons is an ongoing problem. Germany’s most prominent far-right political group, Alternative for Germany (AfD), helped whip up widespread xenophobic and Islamophobic sentiments with a 2017 pre-election advert featuring bikini-clad women and the statement ‘Burkas? We prefer Bikinis’. In 2020, 632 Islamophobic crimes were recorded to the police, including mosque vandalism, harassment of women in headscarves and verbal attacks. And that figure doesn’t account for all the crimes left unreported. Violence frequently affects the LGBTQI+ community, with a 36% rise in hate crimes recorded in 2020. Last October, my sister and her girlfriend were harassed in a restaurant in the far-right frequented area of lake Wandlitz. They didn’t know beforehand this was an unsafe area for those openly queer – it was not ‘just a lake’. 

Belonging does not fall in your lap in Berlin, as suggested by Unorthodox. While the series presents Berlin as a blank slate that invites you to express your true self freely, spoken and unspoken rules exist for those who do not fall within the white German majority, while individuals will be judged based on their skin tone or signalled religious affiliation. Jews have felt pressured to assimilate to dominant German culture since they were granted citizenship in the 19th century. Such pressures to acculturate still exist for the many ethnoreligious minorities who have sought new lives in Germany. 

Unorthodox is undoubtedly powerful, and Debbie Feldman’s story needs to be told. Etsy flees from an oppressive community and seeks greater acceptance in Berlin, as many others have done, and this is an important story to represent. Yet in only representing the positives of Berlin, the series becomes a fanciful EU propaganda that will only help divert much needed attention to tackling the ingrained issues of white supremacy, exclusionary nationalism and economic disparity that have plagued the continent for centuries. Beyond Berlin’s streets, Etsy would feel haunted by the past anywhere in Europe. We have not left it behind, and to suggest we have, is a counterproductive distortion of the present day to the millions of viewers who streamed the show. 

LOS JÓVENES DE LA CIUDAD: VISIÓN MUSULMANA Y JUDÍA

On the 8th of November, 2022, I co-organised a round-table discussion about being young and Jewish/ Muslim in Barcelona. The event was co-organised by Zouhair El Harain and myself, and four members of the Jewish and Muslim communities of Barcelona came to respond to questions regarding secularism, intolerance towards religious minorities in Barcelona and racism. The discussion expanded to the audience and included individuals who had migrated to the city in the 1960s, giving us a sense of how being Jewish and Muslim Barcelonian’s has shifted over the past 40 years. The discussion was part of Salam Shalom Barcelona, a non-profit association exploring Jewish and Muslim relations through a range of lenses, from culture to politics.

Beauty and Islamic Theology: interview

I translated questions written by Dr. Bilal Badat and interviewed Prof. José Miguel Puerta Vílchez, Professor of Art History at Granada University. The interview forms part of a documentary series that explores “Beauty and Islamic Theology” from multiple angles, a joint research program of the Centre for Islamic Theology at the Eberhard-Karls-University Tübingen and the Chair of Islamic Religious Studies at the Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nuremberg.

The interview relates to Professor Vilchez’ 2017 publication ‘Aesthetics in Arabic Thought; From Pre-Islamic Arabic Through Al-Andalus’, published by Brill.

As stated by Dr. Bilal Badat, the questions explored in the video (in Spanish, with English subtitles) include: “What is the nature and significance of beauty in Islamic theology and intellectual thought? To what extent did theological, philosophical, and mystical ideas inform the production and reception of Islamic material culture?”

Conference – PUBLIC JEWISHNESS: CONTEXTS, MOTIVES, POLITICS, MEANING

This was a three-day participant-only workshop bringing PhD candidate ethnographers and established scholars whose work partially explores open representations or inhabitations of Jewishness, particularly in the presence of non-Jews. The symposium discussions focused on public/private distinctions, political and civic engagement, local and state heritagization processes and Jewish enactments of peoplehood. The past and forthcoming ethnographic projects we explored spanned the globe, whether São Paolo Jews and their relation to Brazil’s shift to Bolsonaro’s hard-right politics, Kochin’s Jewish community who are grappling with diminishing populations and Hassidic Jewish individuals who are creatively responding to Netflix documentaries through Yiddish theatre in Canada.

Anthropologists have noted how Jewish socialities have shifted across global contexts since the 1960s to become more public-facing and embedded within socially diverse spaces. The combination of growing socioeconomic infrastructures, such as the global boom of the heritage industry in the 1990s, liberal democratic state-led processes that encourage minority representation and participation within the wider democratic body and shifting Judaic ethical discourses around peoplehood and universalism, have been seen to contribute to the growth of spaces and practices which foster forms of Jewish communal life that play out in more public-facing forms. This symposium aimed to understand public and private Jewishness from a range of angles and contexts, teasing out surprising theoretical intersections between geographically diverse case studies.

The conference, hosted by the Anthropology Department of SOAS University, was designed to provide engagement and guidance to doctoral candidates about to begin ethnographic research, as well as to generate productive conversations across generations of scholars. The workshop was co-organised by Dr.Naomi Leite and myself.

Q&A: The Feeling of History

Through the Jewish-Muslim research Network, I spoke to Associate Professor Charles Hirschkind about his new book, ‘The Feeling of History: Islam, Romanticism and Andalusia’ (see video below).

Read about the book here:

‘In today’s world, the lines between Europe and the Middle East, between Christian Europeans and Muslim immigrants in their midst, seem to be hardening. Alarmist editorials compare the arrival of Muslim refugees with the “Muslim conquest of 711,” warning that Europe will be called on to defend its borders. Violence and paranoia are alive and well in Fortress Europe.

Against this xenophobic tendency, The Feeling of History examines the idea of Andalucismo—a modern tradition founded on the principle that contemporary Andalusia is connected in vitally important ways with medieval Islamic Iberia. Charles Hirschkind explores the works and lives of writers, thinkers, poets, artists, and activists, and he shows how, taken together, they constitute an Andalusian sensorium. Hirschkind also carefully traces the various itineraries of Andalucismo, from colonial and anticolonial efforts to contemporary movements supporting immigrant rights. The Feeling of History offers a nuanced view into the way people experience their own past, while also bearing witness to a philosophy of engaging the Middle East that experiments with alternative futures.’

Charles Hirschkind is associate professor of anthropology at the University of California, Berkeley. His research interests concern religious practice, media technologies, and emergent forms of political community in the urban Middle East and Europe. His published works include, The Ethical Soundscape: Cassette Sermons and Islamic Counterpublics (Columbia 2006), Powers of the Secular Modern: Talal Asad and his Interlocutors (co-edited with David Scott, Stanford 2005), and The Feeling for History: Islam, Romanticism, and Andalusia (Chicago 2020).

Q&A: ‘The Converso’s return’

The Converso’s Return: Conversion and Sephardi History
in Contemporary Literature and Culture

by Professor Dalia Kandiyoti 

I spoke to Dalia Kandiyoti about her new book, The Converso’s Return.

Q & A for the Jewish-Muslim Research Network (JMRN)

December 2, 2020

Co-sponsored by the Middle East and Middle Eastern American Center
(MEMEAC) at the Graduate Center, CUNY

Five centuries after the forced conversion of Spanish and Portuguese Jews to Catholicism, stories of these conversos‘ descendants uncovering long-hidden Jewish roots have come to light and taken hold of the literary and popular imagination. This seemingly remote history has inspired a wave of contemporary writing involving hidden artifacts, familial whispers and secrets, and clandestine Jewish ritual practices pointing to a past that had been presumed dead and buried. The Converso’s Return explores the cultural politics and literary impact of this reawakened interest in converso and crypto-Jewish history, ancestry, and identity, and asks what this fascination with lost-and-found heritage can tell us about how we relate to and make use of the past.

Dalia Kandiyoti’s latest book offers nuanced interpretations of contemporary fictional and autobiographical texts about crypto-Jews in Cuba, Mexico, New Mexico, Spain, France, the Ottoman Empire, and Turkey. These works not only imagine what might be missing from the historical archive but also suggest an alternative historical consciousness that underscores uncommon convergences of and solidarities within Sephardi, Christian, Muslim, converso, and Sabbatean histories. Steeped in diaspora, Sephardi, transamerican, Iberian, and world literature studies, The Converso’s Return illuminates how the converso narrative can enrich our understanding of history, genealogy, and collective memory.

Dalia Kandiyoti is Professor of English at the College of Staten Island, City University of New York. Kandiyoti researches and teaches comparative diaspora studies, American Studies, and world literature.  Her research has focused on Latina/o/x literature, global Sephardi Studies, and comparative studies of migration in the Americas. Prof. Kandiyoti’s current work includes an oral history project  and an edited volume about Sephardi Jews and the citizenship laws in Spain and Portugal, both with Dr. Rina Benmayor. This work has received support for the National Endowment for the Humanities.

Jewish and Muslim Memories of Morocco

Estas entrevistas forma parte de una colección de historias orales que tratan del pasado Judío de Marruecos. La iniciativa, que conduje como un miembro del grupo Salam Shalom Barcelona, intenta preservar las memorias de personas Judías Sefarditas Marroquíes y Musulmanes Marroquíes quien solían vivir en Marruecos. Específicamente, su memorias de la comunidad judía en Marruecos durante el siglo veinte. Salam Shalom es una iniciativa que se explora la cultura Judia y musulmana en Barcelona.

Para ver el resto de los videos:

These interviews are part of a collection of oral hisotires exploring Morocco’s 20th century Jewish history. The initiative, which I led as a member of the group Salam Shalom Barcelona, aims to preserve and compare the memories of Moroccan-Sephardic Jews and Moroccan Muslims who used to live in Morocco, and may still visit there. The interviews focus on their recollections of the Jewish community in Morocco throughout the twentieth century, and their memories of Jewish-Muslim relations. The vast majority of Jews and Muslims in Spain originate from Morocco. Salam Shalom is an NGO exploring Jewish and Muslim culture and history within Barcelona

To see the rest of the videos. Si sabes de un archivo que sería interesado en tener estas entrevistas, enviarnos un correo.

Locación de las entrevistas: Barcelona / Período de coger estas entrevistas: April – August 2019

Una initiativa de Salam Shalom. Supported by Mozaika and Screenshot 2020-05-27 at 10.50.33

Entrevistadora/Interviewer: Flora Hastings

 

 

Moises Israel Benasayag

(Interview in Spanish)

 

 

 

Abdul and Fatimah

(Interview in English)

 

 

Salam Shalom organizó un evento de seguimiento, en asociación con Euroarab and TolDot. Moisés, originario de Tetuán, fue entrevistado por Med Ahsissene y Zouhair El Hairan (también originario de Tetuán) sobre sus recuerdos de su crecimiento y eventualmente huyendo de Tetuán. Luego Toldot nos sirvieron comida marroquí-sefardí.

Salam Shalom organised a follow up event, in partnership with Euroarab and TolDot. Moises, originally from Tétouan, was interviewed by Med Ahsissene and Zouhair El Hairan (also originally from Tétouan) about his memories of growing up and eventually fleeing Tétouan. We were then served Moroccan-Sephardic food cooked by Toldot.

 

 

Photos by Federico Szarfer Barenblit

 

Clips from the event (In Spanish):

 

 

Anthropology Is: Bendy Minds

The best anthropologists make their minds bendy – they try to warp their perspective of the world (how it works, how ‘society’ is organised, what ‘culture’ is) and explore these questions from another perspective (and in doing so, may allow their questions to radically change) Saba Mahmood had the bendiest of minds. She showed up white liberal neo-imperialist feminists and anthropologists who went into Middle Eastern nations and placed Muslim women (from a diverse range of locations) within their white, liberal conceptual frameworks. From their perspectives – if a Muslim woman was observant, she was oppressed. Accordingly, the less Islamic they were, the more ‘liberated’.

What’s the point of anthropology – understanding cultures and societies in their diversity – if you already know what’s good and bad for groups/individuals before hand? if you can just slot them into an oppression/liberation narrative? So Mahmood made her mind bendy – she went and researched a group of Muslim women in the ‘Women’s Mosque Movement’ in Cairo after the Egyptian Revolution. Mahmood saw how the way white liberal feminists understood ‘submission’ was, for this mosque movement, irrelevant. For the practitioners of this all women’s Mosque movement, ‘submission’ to Islamic values was not a oppressive, passive, docile and dogmatic act. Submission meant an active, intellectual and bodily moulding of the self in order to internalise Islamic values and practises until they emerged from the self and body without conscious effort. Submission was a form of empowerment. To understand this, Mahmood had to deconstruct dominant European conceptions of agency, the body and freedom and in turn see how such concepts, applied to the Mosque movement, concealed as opposed to revealed something of the culture which Mahmood was studying. Much Euro-American academia (and especially anthropology), if it doesn’t question itself (and its political agendas), can violently assimilate sociocultural difference to its own terms, hierarchies and views of the world.

The best anthropologists, like Saba Mahmood, endlessly question the terms through which they understand different social and cultural groups. Many Egyptian Islamic feminists disagreed with the Women’s Mosque Movement relation to submission, although that doesn’t discount the need to understand a multitude of perspectives on the matter of women’s diverse experiences of freedom and oppression.

Read Mahmood Cairo ethnography in her 2004 Politics of Piety.

A Century of Women Who Changed Literature: the 1930s

 

Commissioned by Ponder journal

 

Hurston, a prolific folklorist and novelist who documented the African American culture of the rural South, died penniless in 1960. Her writings were tossed into a fire outside her house after her death, left to burn until a passing friend salvaged them from the flames. 15 years later, the renowned novelist Alice Walker would stoke a different kind of fire when her essay ‘Looking for Zora’ led to widespread recognition of Hurston’s talents.

Their Eyes Were Watching God, Hurston’s most famous novel, is as politically relevant today as it was in the 1930s. The novel’s controversial use of language brings the voices of those who are often silenced into centre-stage. The novel follows the tales of its protagonist, Janie Crawford, as she relays her life to her friend, Phoeby. Janie leads Phoeby through stories of her domineering husbands, the claustrophobic micro-politics of porch-side gossip, the Okeechobee hurricane and eventually, to her final love and partner, Tea Cake. The story is part set in Eatonville, an all African American town in Southern Florida where Hurston herself grew up.

 

The book caused a literary backlash after its publication for its extensive use of African-American dialect. Across a 1930s America still plagued with the racist ideology that had legitimised slavery just decades earlier, “serious” literature was equated with standardised English (the language of the media, universities, the “educated”). The judgements given to certain styles of speech and writing were often steeped in racist and classist hierarchies as white supremacist ideology had influenced the mainstream to see African-American dialect as proof of a lack of education and “non-seriousness”.

Despite pressures from the literary world to do so, Hurston refused to translate the African-American dialect of the novel’s characters into standardised English. Such a move would have culturally misrepresented the groups within the novel. Beyond this ideological choice, Hurston artfully plays around with the voice of the book’s narrator*. While the novel’s narrator begins by using standardised English, as the story progresses and Janie rids herself of her misogynistic husbands, the narrator progressively picks up Janie’s dialect. By the end of the novel, Janie’s voice seeps into the narrator’s: ‘‘Janie fooled around outside awhile to try and it wasn’t so”. Janie’s increasing control over the book’s narrative is symbolised by her emboldening refusals to speak at the behest of others. As Janie sat in court at the novel’s close: “She didn’t plead to anybody”.

Janie’s growing empowerment is mirrored by Hurston’s as a novelist – both women refused to mould their speech or writing to the racist and patriarchal hierarchies of early 20th century America; predictably, the novel yielded little success after its publication in 1937.

As a doctoral student in Anthropology, Hurston’s work forms a guide for how I aim to write. Anthropology, which Hurston trained in, is about understanding how groups and individuals comprehend the world from their given perspectives. Within anthropology, language is seen as a crucial way through which individual or group identity is formed – it’s integral to how people organise and comprehend their reality. Unlike many anthropologists at the time, Hurston refused to speak over those she researched and wrote about, allowing her to thrust the voices of communities into a domain which often relied on representations of such groups by others, which were misinformed at best and unequivocally racist at worst.

Taking Hurston’s example beyond 1930s America and anthropology, how would present-day European xenophobia be different if people listened to migrants’ voices more than their representation by right-wing papers like the Daily Mail?

 

*the term used by the literary critics Barbara Johnson and Henry Louis Gates

*the narrator of many of Hurston’s novels is often a non-personal voice which narrates the main events of the novel, distinguished from speaking characters (who are identified by speech marks).

Remembering the anti-fascist Jewish radicals of the ’40s

commissioned by Huck magazine

I’ve always wondered how my grandparents ended up getting married. My grandmother loved going to classical music concerts, while my grandad loved jazz nights. My grandmother would drag him to the opera where he would invariably fall asleep; while my grandad would try and get her to go car racing, which she would always refuse (it messed up her hair). It’s even more strange to think that, not long before they met in the ’50s, my grandad John Wimborne was punching fascists and being arrested for attempted murder.

I was completely unaware of my grandad’s anti-fascist activism as a child. I only learnt about his history with The 43 Group a decade later, after he’d passed away, when my grandmother handed me a heavy folder of newspaper clippings. It was his homemade archive, filled with newspaper articles documenting the groups’ controversial political activism.

The 43 Group were a grassroots initiative, predominantly made up of Jewish ex-soldiers, who fought the rising wave of fascism in ’40s Britain. Their main tactic, for which they were notorious across the UK, was using their World War II military training to shut down fascist rallies.

70 years later, as far-right voices become louder and more influential in modern politics, the group’s legacy of direct political action could not be more relevant.

Along with the rest of Europe, the UK experienced a rapid growth in fascism in the ’30s. Britain’s pin-up fascist was Oswald Mosely, who founded the British Union of Fascists. Mosely’s political speeches were filled with antisemitic vitriol. The ultra-nationalistic, upper-class demagogue pinned the nation’s perceived decline on the thousands of Jewish immigrants in the UK, many of whom had fled the pogroms of the Russian empire.

Amongst them were my grandad’s parents. Depending on which uncle you ask, they either came to the UK from Poland or Ukraine in 1918 or 1890, with the family name of the Bumchicks or the Weinbergs. After arriving, they opted instead for the British-sounding surname ‘Wimborne’  – a word that was apparently glimpsed on a road sign to Wimborne Minster.

The ‘Wimbornes’ arrived to an east London divided between the British working class and Jewish Eastern European immigrants. Poverty reports from the early 20th century note the dark-bearded men in Russian-Polish dress, the wigs of orthodox Jewish woman, and their unplaceable Yiddish tongue. From the perspective of the ‘native’ East Londoners, the spike in Jewish refugees pushed up rent prices and increased unemployment.

Mosely became a beacon of hope to many struggling working-class families, angry at a lack of state support. He offered a vision of Britain for the British, partly gained through deporting a large number of Jewish immigrants. Mosely’s fascist rallies would incite the destruction of Jewish homes and synagogues, the chanting of Nazi anthems and ‘Jew-beating’ on East London’s streets.

Even after the decisive defeat of Europe’s fascist forces by the end of World War II, around 1,000 loyal fans gathered to greet Mosely in his first re-appearance after the war in 1946. “They screamed and raised their arms to give the old fascist salute,” described BBC journalist Trevor Grundy, who witnessed the event. Before long, the old tune of “The Yids, the Yids, we’ve got to get rid of the Yids” soon returned to London’s streets.

The 43 Group formed in 1946 as a defiant response to the mounting fascist threat. With the government refusing to ban the fascist rallies, despite the desperate petitions of the Jewish community, a group of Jewish men and women saw violence and espionage as the only means through which to confront Mosely and his footmen. “It started again, this ‘keep quiet’ business, but we were not going to keep quiet,” ex-43 Group member Stanley Mocks recalled.

Mainly formed by Jewish ex-servicemen and women, The 43 Group translated the skills they had learnt on the battlefields of World War II to the streets of London.  The violence involved was justified – it was seen as an extension of their objective during the war: defeat the fascists.

Speaking in a London History Group documentary, 43 Group co-founder Morris Beckman recalled “flying wedges of hard-cased men” knocking down the podiums of fascist rallies. Knuckle dusters, potatoes stuffed with razor blades, and tightly wound newspapers were tools to attack the fascists in bloody street-brawls. There were no logged fatalities from the fights, but hospitalisation was not unheard of. Many 43-Groupers, women and men, would train weekly in a West End gym. Non-Jews were recruited to infiltrate fascist groups, enabling secret lists of forthcoming rally locations to be shared. The 43 Group slowly expanded, with four offices in London and nearly 1,000 members.

Despite the group’s palpable curbing of fascism, they were denounced by representatives of the Anglo-Jewish community such as The Board of Deputies of British Jews. The 43 Group’s violent tactics raised fears that they would tarnish the public reputation of Anglo-Jewry.

My grandad was only 18 when he helped found the group. Having gained two years of military training in the Royal Navy, he split his time between working at his father’s West End hat shop and fighting violent antisemites. Just one year later, in 1947, both the group and my grandfather were catapulted into the public sphere.

On the night of December 22, 1947, Charles Preen, a prominent fascist, claimed that he had been shot at. In a clipping preserved in my grandfather’s archive, Preen told the Evening Standard that “there was a bang and something whizzed past my face”. A few days after the shooting, he would single out my grandfather in a police line-up. “Preen came forward, looked straight at me and pointed me out,” reads Wimborne’s alibi, also stored in his archive.

In a show of solidarity, fellow 43 Group co-founder Gerry Flamberg – who had not been singled out in the same identity parade – stepped forward and commanded to be charged alongside my grandfather. Like that, the pair were both put on trial with attempted murder.

The enduring battle between fascists and anti-fascists was suddenly brought into a high-profile court case, and the nation was watching. The 43 Group anxiously sought a defence lawyer: Sir Maxwell Fyfe, one of the principal prosecutors for Britain at the Nuremberg Trials. His steep legal fees were paid for by the donations which flooded into The 43 Group from across the UK.

With Preen’s history of antisemitic acts and his tenuous court evidence, the magistrate described him as a witness he could not believe. After a brief trial, Wimborne and Flamberg were acquitted as not guilty. It was a clear setup. The trial would become a symbol of anti-fascist triumph for years to come. (In a 43 Group reunion 50 years after the event, Flamberg denied the charge with his characteristic bravado: “I’m supposed to be a crack shot, I wouldn’t have missed it!”)

During the three years following the trial, fascism in the UK slowly declined. With little need for the 43 Group to be on the prowl, the group officially disbanded in 1950. In a ritualistic end, confidential documents were burnt to impede potential investigations into their illegal shenanigans, such as allegedly being helped by the infamous Jewish East End gangster Jack “Spot”.

My grandad’s confrontation of fascists has influenced my involvement with Jewish groups who are committed to meeting the enemy face-to-face – minus the tactics of hardcore violence. Militant anti-fascist Jewish fronts in the UK no longer exist. However, Jewish groups such as Jewdas are often first in the counter-demonstrations of far-right marches, raising funds for anti-fascist organisations through debauched Jewish themed parties.

Many of Jewdas’ members – I am now one myself – can be seen wearing anti-fascist badges, and disrupting neo-fascist rallies with jeers and signs. And with the rise of the far-right across Europe today, the importance of these kinds of groups is paramount. Marches such as Tommy Robinson’s ‘Brexit Betrayal March last year, which gathered between 3000 to 5000 supporters in central London, prove the emboldening of those with deeply xenophobic and racist views. The surge in far-right support no doubt correlates to the rise in antisemitic attacks measured in the UK, with 16 per cent more anti-Jewish hate incidents in 2018, not to mention the steep climb in Islamophobic attacks.

As with The 43 Group in the 1940s, Jewdas’ radical, anti-establishment ethos leads to frequent denunciations from both The Board of Deputies and the mainstream press. However, this just shows that we should never forget the history that came before us. The 43 Group may have used questionable tactics, but we can take lessons from their boldness, spirit, and willingness to take action – our futures may depend on it.

The Unsung Savior of Cairo’s Jewish Community

commissioned by Haaretz

 

At first glance, the 92-year-old man sitting in a Parisian apartment and clutching a book to his chest does not look in the least bit like the hero at the center of a tale of a high-stakes escape.

However, this is exactly who Clement Behar was: The unsung savior of Cairo’s Jews, who risked his own life to rescue members of the community from persecution in the 1940s and 1950s.

Clement Behar recounts his story of saving Cairo’s JewsFlora Hastings / Haaretz

Forty-six years later, his story is still emerging from obscurity – Behar, formerly known as Chehata, has published a memoir in which he revealed how he helped release scores of Jews from Cairo’s prisons. The self-published oeuvre, titled “A Story of a Life with a Difference,” came out in 2003.

Born in 1925, Behar grew up in the Egyptian capital at a time when the city was a Jewish, Muslim and Christian cosmopolis. Joining his father’s prospering electrical business at 15, he was propelled to Egypt’s elite social circles. As a teen, he saw anti-colonial movements gain more traction shortly after the British Empire granted nominal independence to his homeland in 1922.

His family, much like many other Egyptian Jews, enjoyed financial and social success. But in 1948 matters took a turn for the worse: Israel was established as an independent state after Jewish militants defeated the British Mandate of Palestine. A day later, on May 15, the War of Independence broke out. The young country survived the invasion of five Arab nations which opposed Jews taking over Arab lands. It even gained control over more territories, sparking a deep anti-Jewish sentiment in the region.

A portrait of Clement Behar aged 28, taken in 1953.
Flora Hastings

At the time, Egypt was home to 80,000 Jews who resided there for three millennia, with some immigrating from Europe since the late 19th century. Despite their stature, the country’s Jews were put in a precarious position over their alleged loyalty to Israel. Many of them perceived themselves as more Egyptian than Jewish, and rejected calls by Egypt’s growing ethnonationalist circle to leave.

The calls quickly escalated into violence. One infamous incident is the Balfour Day riots, which took place in November 1945. They began as anti-Jewish demonstrations on the 28th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration, but quickly turned into altercations in which five Egyptian Jews were killed and hundreds were injured. In 1948, the riots worsened. Hundreds were murdered, Jewish synagogues were burned down and Jewish areas in the country were bombed. Many Jews were jailed, often on suspicion that they had spied for Israel.

This is when Behar’s operation was set in motion. “Every day, officers arrested young Jewish people, and their families came to see me and enlist my help,” he wrote in his memoir. 

‘Obliged to help the Jews’

In 1953 the Egpytian Republic was born, and gave rise to a national socialist president – Gamal Abdel Nasser. Egypt was finally freed from the British occupation, but the Jewish community only suffered from these developments. The Pan-Arabist movement continued to grow under Nasser, and Jews were seen as an obstacle to its goal: Uniting all Arab nations into a single state. By 1950, 40 percent of Egyptian Jews fled. “I felt morally obliged to help the Jews,” Behar told Haaretz.

He began to do so, using his close friendship with a high-ranking police officer named El Hamichari. Behar negotiated the release of imprisoned Jews through “gifts and bribes.” Dressed neatly and wearing a traditional fez, the young Behar easily entered and left Cairo’s police stations, where he was often mistaken for an officer thanks to his command of Egyptian Arabic.

The Jewish community continued to shrink. 14,000 Jews had escaped to Israel, while others sought refuge in different countries. Egypt’s chief rabbi also became a target. In his memoir, Behar wrote that in 1954 President Nasser sent Rabbi Nahoum Effendi a “poisoned invitation.”

To mobilize anti-Israel sentiment, Effendi was called on to give a speech publicly denouncing the Jewish state. The rabbi “prayed that he would be spared the ordeal,” Behar wrote, but was powerless to decline the invitation.

Cairo's former chief rabbi, Nahoum Effendi (second from the left) with Behar (furthest to the right).
Flora Hastings

Behar decided to save the rabbi. He enlisted the help of a daring Jewish hospital manager, Dr. Bensimmon, who prescribed medication for the rabbi as well as “a very strict diet which made him actually unwell.” The national papers reported that Effendi was very ill and could not attend the event. Behar wrote about the chief rabbi’s gratitude. “May God keep you near me to have you by my side in difficult times,” he told Behar.

The prison escape  

Behar continued his operations to aid the Jewish community in its plight, but eventually his luck ran out. Egyptian police caught him smuggling money out of the country for the chief rabbi’s son. As he waited for his trial, Behar wrote a letter to his wife Dorette and their four children. He begged them to flee Egypt immediately. After he was sentenced to six years of hard labor behind bars, Behar “decided to escape there and then.”

In his memoir, Behar wrote that he wore civilian clothing prior to his trial. Exploiting his attire and the prison’s shortage of guards, he made his big escape. “I went downstairs, I walked to the prison gates and just walked out of prison,” he recollected.

Clement Behar's false Lebanese identity card.
Flora Hastings

From there, Behar bolted to a Christian monastery where he sought cover with the help of a monk he befriended when the latter paid visits to the prison. Behar wrote that for 18 months he was on the run. “I shaved my moustache. I work dark glasses and started running in all directions, incognito, to find a way of escape. I would return to the monastery at night,” he wrote.

After close to two years at large, Behar acquired a false Lebanese identity card under the name Sami Refaat Abdul Hadi. His cover story was that he was Muslim businessman. “I knew Arabic perfectly well. No one would have suspected that I was Jewish,” Behar wrote. Later, he was aided by a high-ranking police officer named Captain Said Nached, who sheltered him in his home until he was finally able to board a flight to Damascus.

Longing for Egypt

In 1956, Behar moved on from Syria to Lebanon. He was able to seek shelter there because Beirut and Cairo were political enemies at the time – then-Lebanese President Camille Chamoun, a Christian Maronite, was seriously opposed to Nasser’s Pan Arabism.

As a political refugee, Behar resided in the magisterial mansion of the president’s secretary for several months. He also managed to obtain a Lebanese passport. “After being sheltered in a monastery, I was familiar with all the prayers and Christian traditions. I was very much in need of that in the circle I was mixing in at that time,” he related in the memoir.

Later, Baher was able to secure a visa from Switzerland and made his way to France, where his wife and sons were living. In 1958 he arrived in a northern suburb of Paris as an illegal refugee, where at long last he reunited with his family. “‘They are all here! In the twinkling of an eye, I had forgotten everything: Jail, my walkabout, my nightmares.”

Speaking to Haaretz decades after his fugitive journey ended, Behar teared up when he talked about Egypt. Asked how he felt about his exile from his native land, Behar responded: “I spent at least 25 years locked up inside myself because of leaving Egypt, my roots and identity. It took me that long to accept that I live in Europe.” Despite the many years he spent in France, Behar said that he still felt more “Egyptian and Arab than Jewish.”

Six months after our interview, Behar passed away in October 2017. He did not hear of Egyptian President Abdel-Fattah al-Sissi’s surprising recent overture in which he offered to build synagogues in Egypt should members of the Jewish community choose to return. Behar himself only went back to Egypt once in 1980. In his memoir he wrote of a walk along Cairo’s Jewish quarter, where he found “the synagogue which had fallen to pieces… All I had was a blow to the heart.” He told Haaretz that his feeling was that he “returned as a tourist.”

Writing the memoir helped Behar accept his journey, but he remained ambivalent about his homeland until his death. His is a tale of triumph; it is also a story of bitterness and longing, which linger with may other Jews who were forced to flee their Middle Eastern homes a century ago.

The New Spanish Islamophobia

 

Published by The New Internationalist 

 

Tanned, muscular men ride stallions across a rural landscape. Plaintive piano plays in the background. Where are these men? The title of Vox’s political campaign video tells you: ‘The Reconquista will begin in the lands of Andalusia’.

This controversial slogan is part of a strategy that helped secure the rising far-right party twelve seats in Andalusia’s regional election last year. Next week, Vox are one of five main contenders in Spain’s general elections, signalling the party’s unanticipated growth. It is expected to receive 29-37 per cent of the vote.

The Reconquista, meaning the ‘reconquering’, draws on the history of the Iberian Christian conquest of Muslim Spain, which ended in 1492. Vox’s proposed political reforms make the relevance of this history clear: if elected, the party claims it will deliver an end to supposed uncurbed migration, placate the ‘threat’ to Spain’s national identity from the growth of Islam, end state-funded abortion and repeal gay marriage laws.

Spectres of the past

The history of medieval Christian-Muslim conflict forms this far-right party’s repertoire of symbolism. For eight centuries, Spain was governed by Islamic rulers, known as the Moors. In 711 CE, the governing Umayyad dynasty travelled from Syria to Spain and eventually conquered the then Visigothic lands, renaming them ‘al-Andalus’. Contemporary Spain is replete with vestiges of this past, from Moorish architecture to the many Arabic-origin words in the Spanish language.

With the end of the Reconquista in 1492, a Spanish national identity began to emerge. The newly reigning Catholic monarchs took violent measures to forge it. Those who were not Catholic would not be considered Spanish in this new social order. This process would eventually lead to the expulsion of the peninsula’s vast Jewish and Muslim populations.

Spanish ethno-nationalism continued well into the 20th century. Spain’s former dictator, General Franco, granted the Catholic Church immense power, prohibited any religion save Catholicism and enforced the standardisation of ‘core’ Spanish culture, from the Castilian language to bullfighting. Francoist Spanish nationalism was defined against the nation’s former Jewish and Muslim subjects, such as through the dictator’s heavy use of Spanish Reconquista symbolism in his propaganda. Francoist rhetoric even blended the myth of the ever-present ‘Moorish threat’ to Spain with the ‘menace’ of Eastern European communism.

With the death of Franco in 1975, Spain officially disbanded its explicitly authoritarian structure. However, its ethno-nationalist past still haunts the public sphere.

‘Spanishness’

Moroccans are Spain’s second largest minority. Many within Spain’s Moroccan community are ancestrally related to Spain’s historic Muslim population. At a market in Cordoba, pejoratively called ‘Morro’s Mercado’ by locals, Tariq, a Moroccan vendor tells me about the strong anti-Muslim prejudice he recognises in Andalusia: ‘They think in Morocco there are only camels and the desert,’ he says. Beyond the perception of Morocco as an excessively ‘backwards’ country, some Spaniards even perceive the influx of Moroccan immigrants to Spain since the 1970s as posing a ‘re-Islamization’ of the country.

Outside more blatantly Islamophobic cases, there are Spanish traditions which revisit this Christian-Muslim schism. Each year on 2 January, individuals across Spain dress as either ‘Moros’ or ‘Christianos’ and re-enact the last battle of the Reconquista, where the medieval stereotypes of the Moors as violent and religiously fanatic are inflated through carnivalesque caricatures.

Although these cultural rituals are thought to commemorate a strife from a by-gone past, Vox’s dogwhistle calls for a new Reconquista casts these cultural rituals in an even darker light, further entrenching the idea of Muslims as antithetical to ‘Spanishness’.

Acceptable in the mainstream

Appeals to the Reconquista are not a new development in Spanish politics. In an attempt to drum up support for the Iraq War, José Aznar, Spain’s former Conservative prime minister, explicitly linked the medieval Moors to al-Qaeda. He stated in 2004 that ‘the problem of Spain with al-Qaeda began with the invasion of the Moors’, who were repelled thanks to the ‘successful Reconquista’.

Vox is building on this rhetoric. The party’s leader, Santiago Abascal, petitioned for Andalusia’s regional day to celebrate the conclusion of the Reconquista in 1492. At a meeting in Seville, Abascal stated that he wanted the ‘Andalusia of the Catholic Monarchs against that of Blas Infante’. Infante was a libertarian socialist writer known as the father of Andalusian nationalism. In the early 20th century, he strived to turn Spain’s legacy of medieval Jewish, Muslim and Christian co-existence into a contemporary reality.

The language used in the party’s political speeches is rife with Islamophobia. Vox’s secretary general, Javier Ortega Smith, stated in 2016 that ‘the enemy of Europe is called the Islamist invasion’. Santiago Abascal, Vox’s leader, rejoined Smith by stating that Spain’s Muslim community will become a ‘problem’ in an interview last year. The party’s proposed political reforms include banning both Islamic education and halal food in Spanish state schools.

This is all part of a Europe-wide phenomenon. In the week following the New Zealand/Aotearoa mosque shootings on 15 March, the number of anti-Muslim hate crimes reported across Britain increased by 593 per cent. These attacked are fuelled by continent-wide stereotypes, from the perception of Muslims as jihadists to perceiving Muslim immigrants as an unassailable threat to Western values.

Vox’s anti-Muslim stance have helped win the party favour with Europe’s largest far-right political groups. In 2017, Abascal claimed an affinity with France’s ultra-conservative Marine Le Pen for their mutual protection of ‘Christian Europe’. Le Pen, along with the Netherland’s far-right Geert Wilders, have openly supported Vox through expressing hopes that the party will gain seats in May’s European parliamentary elections. The growing coordination between Europe’s far-right parties only threatens to strengthen the institutional legs of a continent-wide Islamophobia. 

Jewish history caught in independence tug-of-war

 

Published for Jewish Renaissance Journal

 

After a 400-year vacuum, Judaism has reappeared on the Iberian Peninsula in unexpected ways. Spanish institutions have proudly united medieval Sephardi identity with a modern Spanish identity. Meanwhile, Catalan institutions recently asserted that their medieval Jewish communities had a separate Catalan identity.

In the 1990s the Spanish government revived an interest in Sephardi history and formed La Red de Juderias, a multi-million-euro Jewish tourism network. Spain’s Jewish archaeological sites were renovated and archives digitised to rediscover this unknown legacy. ‘Spanish’ and ‘Sephardi’ became interchangeable terms in the Red’s publications.

The pluralism of the medieval La Convivencia – an era of intellectual symbiosis between Muslims, Jews and Christians – was reimagined as being the foundation of Spain’s current progressive identity. The act of connecting modern Spain with the past was a precursor to the 2015 Law of Return for Sephardi Jews. The introduction of the law can be seen as an attempt to diversify Spain’s national image.

But which Spain? Medieval Spain was built by Jews, Muslims and Christians who coexisted under La Convivencia. The Catholic, Castilian Spain that followed, whose foundations support today’s nation, has little to do with this history. The Law of Return requires proof of the applicant’s ‘special connection’ to Spain through a Spanish language and culture test. Most Right of Return laws, such as those of Germany or Poland, do not require this.

Alfons Aragoneses, head of law at Barcelona’s Pompeu Fabra University, questions the historical accuracy of Spain’s identification with Sephardi Jews: “Spain did not exist before 1492, but the law supposes that the Sephardim were conscious of belonging to Spain and that they were always nostalgic for Spain. Spain did not exist until the 19th century!” At least, the Spain that formed after the 1492 union of the Castilian and Aragonese Crown did not exist when the Sephardim lived on the Peninsula.

Catalonia too has been weaving nationalistic threads into its Jewish past. Tessa Calders, the daughter of the renowned Republican exile Pere Calders, has been calling for the current interpretation of Jewish medieval history to be revised and the adapted version to be recognised in any representation of Jewish history. “The Jews were kicked out of Spain and lost memory of their Catalan identity. Now Spain has reinvented their past,” says Calders, who is a lecturer in Hebrew at the University of Barcelona. She believes the Jews living in northern Spain before the expulsion were not Sephardi but were Catalonian.

This pro-Catalan understanding of history has been embraced by Catalonia’s regional governments: in 2016, five municipalities split from the Red de Juderias to create a new tourism network, the Xarxa de Calls. Jusep Boya is the head of Museums for Catalonia and the manager of this new organisation. In his office off Barcelona’s Las Ramblas, he envisaged the new network as a vehicle for Catalonia’s reconnection with its Jewish history. “We cannot comprehend Catalonia without the Jewish culture which is attached to the very soul of Catalonia,” he said.

Pancracio Celdrán, a former professor of medieval history at Haifa University, disputes that there was a conscious 15th-century Catalan identity. “These medieval ‘Catalan Jewries’ were really the Jews of the Kingdom of Aragon, not of Catalonia.” Others say that Catalonian nationhood only developed in the 19th century.

With only 40,000 Jews in Spain today, the groups who should have a platform to challenge these revisions of history have no representational power. Most of those involved in the departments for Jewish tourism in both governments are not Jewish and have little specialisation in the history of Jews living in Spain. The situation needs addressing: Spain was ranked the third most antisemitic country in Europe in a 2014 survey. Instead of politicising Sephardi identity for their own narratives, isn’t it time for both sides to let the Sephardim delineate their own ancestral past?

Kings In The Alhambra, Tanks In Barcelona

 

 

Published by Novara Media

Re-published by Edge of Humanity Magazine (abridged version)

 

The latest independence referendum in Catalonia has been declared illegal and central government has offered the region a simple choice; abandon the plans for the referendum or lose all their budgetary powers. This battle for Catalonian independence is among the latest in a long history of cultural struggles in Spain, where individual cultural, religious and ethnic groups find themselves at odds with authorities wishing to impose a monolithic, centralised vision of Spanish history. 

Decapitating history in Barcelona.

Judging by the decapitation of the late Spanish dictator last October, the past is still contentious between Spain and Catalonia. The assailant, and Franco’s head, was never found. The headless statue remained stationed outside El Born’s Cultural Centre of Memory, housing 18th century archeological remains from Barcelona. The centre’s objective: “to promote the memory and reflection of local and national events“.

Franco’s caste-iron silhouette atop his horse, stood close to the door leading to the hundreds of Catalan artefacts uncovered 27 years ago. The ceramics and metal-work evidence Catalonia’s artisan history. The fragments disrupt Franco’s myth of Spain having a unified national identity. Under the dictator’s 36 year rule, Catalonia’s cultural identity was strangled.

Cultural difference was erased in the many distinct areas of Spain, namely the Catalonian and Basque regions. Catalan was banned, spoken largely only in closed quarters, while ancient Catalan traditions, from Correfoc to Els Castells, were made illegal. Camp Nou, Barcelona’s football stadium, was one of the only places where Catalonians could speak their language. Even now, the crowds at the games are peppered with independence flags.

 

cat1A Catalan Independence march last November, by Barcelona’s Placa Espana.

 

To see the placing of the two statues of Franco so close to the centre’s doors as a provocative statement is only my reading. The figures were part of an exhibition entitled, Franco: Victory, Republic and Impunity in Urban Spaces. Their stated purpose was to encourage a re-interpretation of Spain’s Francoist history.

During the Spanish Civil war of 1936-9, Franco’s Nationalists forcefully took power from the Republican party, ending the country’s democratic rule. The death toll proliferated when Franco invited Hitler to test his bombs on Republican civilians. Barcelona was the centre of Catalonia’s historically Republican population.

The city’s current mayor, Ada Colau, gained her political experience in street protests and city activism, not in parliament. Barcelona has a long history of revolutionary anarchism, further evidenced by the controversy of the exhibition’s gesture. Civilians passing through El Born would have parents who were on the Nationalist or Republican side during the regime, with these divisions still kept alive in many families.

The responses to the statues materialised not in introspective meditations but in physical acts of violence: the decapitation, the eggs and graffiti decorating his body like farcical war-ribbons, the pig-head placed on the severed neck. A Catalonian, whose family had been Republican under Franco, had to be restrained when he tried to punch a worker installing the statue. The figures were removed after only 48 hours of their showing.

On October 1, the Regional Catalan government will hold a de facto independence referendum whose results could see an immediate split from Spain, despite a lack of national government sanctioning. The question on the draft legislations is simple: “Do you want Catalonia to be a state that is independent from Spain?”

Many Catalonians want independence not simply to re-affirm their separateness and explore their recent history without the censorship of central government, but to distance themselves from the way that this past still lingers within Spain’s current government, the conservative Christian-Democratic Partido Popular (PP), which was founded by a former minister under Franco’s regime. This past haunts the party, sewing historical devisions that the PP have not addressed, and leading to efforts to control the way this past is remembered.

 

dog2A Catalan Independence march last November, by Barcelona’s Placa Espana.

 

The ‘Pact of Forgetting’.

The PP is not the pioneer of Spain’s historic stitching up of the past – rather, it’s a faithful heir. This official approach to the past began in 1977, with the passing of the ‘Pact of Forgetting’to facilitate the move into a fledging democracy. This law made it illegal to persecute any of Franco’s officials. Investigation or official condemnation of their crimes were also prohibited, unlike the rest of Europe who’s fallen dictatorships saw extensive trials. As a result of this law, still in place today, the way that the history of the regime and civil war can be officially taught is highly controlled in state syllabuses.

The current Spanish government’s website echoes the centralised version of the nation’s historical memory, claiming that the transition to democracy in the 1970s showed that “all the wounds from the civil war had been healed”. History textbooks today still refuse to indict Franco’s Nationalists for shedding more blood than the Republicans, stating that both sides are equally culpable: “In a graveyard far off there is a corpse, who has moaned for three years.”

 

span4A Spanish patriot in Barcelona on the 12th of October, The National Day of Spain.

The Pact has more tangible effects than how history is recalled. The law limits the allowance of families to exhume the mass graves within Spain where their relatives are buried. Federico Garcia Lorca, a renowned Spanish poet rumoured to be one of artist Salvador Dali’s lovers, lies beneath the country’s soil. Killed by a firing squad in 1939, Lorca was buried in a mass grave, alongside thousands of other Republicans. Since 2008, Baltasar Garzon, one of Spain’s most renowned jurists, has unsuccessfully called for a repeal of the Pact three times. Garzon had tried to call for the exhumation of 19 graves, one which may have hidden the poet.

Fiscal controls over historical memory.

The PP’s support of this law, which they claim prevents groups with historical Nationalist and Republican roots from re-sewing divisions, embodies their desire to protect the memory of Francoist Spain. This desire manifests through the wider measures the party takes to limit the self-scrutinising excavation of history. The PP have little political incentive to disturb the allegedly still waters of Spain’s historical memory.

Conservative values consolidated under Franco’s regime survived its collapse. To this day, public institutions lean heavily on Castilian language and culture, traditional Catholic church values and the symbolic power of the monarchy – values which play well with the party’s  large conservative votership.

Manuel Fraga’s role as senator of the PP until 2011 was a prologue to the party’s multiplying efforts to protect the legacy of the Francoist past. Fraga was the Tourism and Foreign Affairs minister under Franco. He ordered the execution of the Communist leader Julian Grimau by gun shot. After Franco’s death, he earned the epithet “¡La calle es mía!” (The streets are mine), due to his ardent repression of street protests through police violence. When he died in 2012, the El Pais newspaper awkwardly proffered the following take: “He was famous for his seemingly endless energy” – delicately skirting around his violent past and keeping to his political achievements of the 21st century. Their retelling of Fraga’s history, through euphemisms and polite omissions, reflects the government’s own approach. In 2009, the European Parliament wanted to include Francoism as part of their day recalling European totalitarianism. The PP refused to join the discussions, while the Conservative Spanish MEP, Jaime Mayor Oreja claimed that “it would be historically foolish” to disrupt the fabled peace of Spain’s transition to democracy. The past’s physical remnants are also guarded. Public funds still pay for the maintenance of The Valley of the Fallen – a vast mausoleum in Madrid that houses Franco’s body with a public mass each year held to commemorate his death.

In 2004, José Zapatero’s left-wing government stood to challenge . With less stake than the PP detoxification of public memories of the Franco regime, the party took the first legal steps to begin dredging up the crimes of the country’s past. Zapatero introduced The Historical Memory law in 2006.  For the first time, the law funded the exhumation of mass graves of Republicans, awarded rights to Franco’s victims and removed hundreds of Francoist monuments. The law also allowed for Spain’s different regions to advance their own understanding of history in school textbooks, shattering the centralised version of previous education administrations.

However, with the PP elected to power in 2011, the need for such a law was openly denied by its leader, Mariano Rajoy. The past was back in the hands of the right. “I would eliminate all the articles in the historical memory law that mention using public funds to recover the past. I wouldn’t give even a single euro of public funds for that”, he told Spanish media, following his election as president. Withdrawing all government funding to the program was one of the first things he did in his ascent to power in 2011; the offices involved were closed.

 

 

IMG_0942A political pero in Barcelona on the 12th of October, The National Day of Spain (Pro-Spanish unity march)

 

Spain’s unstable foundations.

The PP’s control over the way history is remembered, should be read in the wider context of their handling over how Spain’s national identity is understood. The PP is the natural heir to five centuries of governmental efforts to centralise and homogenise the question of what – and indeed who – counts as properly Spanish. Diverse groups who might disagree with this monolith vision of Spanish identity have historically been silenced, and still are today; from geographical and cultural groupings of the Catalonians, Basques to religious and ethnic groups such as Muslims and Sephardim.

We must understand contemporary wranglings over Catalonian independence as part of a longer historical struggle, even if this articulation of separatist groups only mobilised in the early 20th century. Equally, this tradition of control inherited from Franco by the PP, stretches back from the first rulers that pioneered the formation of modern Spain.  To look at the formation of the nation itself contextualises current devisions over the proper answer to the question of who is Spanish.

The Alhambra is a palatial fortress sitting on the hills of Granada in Southern Spain. Before Spain claimed this region, it sat within the lands of the Iberian Peninsula, and was part of the regional Moorish kingdom of the 13th century.  The building’s geometrical patterns and Arabesque aesthetics were constructed by Muslim, Jewish and Christian craftsmen. These religions lived in the Iberian Peninsula in a complex, pluralistic society: three cultures under Muslim and Christian rule. Conflict existed between the groups, but there were no forced conversions. When the Catholic crowns of Aragon and Castile united in 1492, the compound identity of the Iberian Peninsula became Catholic. The monarchs had been slowly claiming the lands of the Peninsula from its Muslim rulers, until the inquisition of the 15th century when the remaining Moors fled. The Catholics had demanded conversion, or expulsion. With the clearing of the peninsula, the process of the formation of Spain’s nation-state identity began. Isabelle and Ferdinand eventually made the Alhambra their royal court, and its symbolic power as a testament to a multicultural society was co-opted. Spain’s identity formalised with the union of the Catholic crowns of Aragon and Castile in 1492.

The Castilian’s gradual imposition of a national identity expanded to its neighbours. The laws of Castile were eventually imposed on Catalonia in 1716. Castilian, one of the many languages spoken within Spain, came to mean Spanish. Spanishness became synonymous with being white, Castilian and Catholic. After two short-lived republics, and a long line of Catholic monarchs, Franco intended to continue writing this story into the 20th century:

The costs of not being considered ‘Spanish’ were steep, when these characteristics became pre-requisites to being incorporated into the nation’s corpus. I spoke to Victor Sorrenson, in his office in the oldest Sephardic synagogue in Barcelona, about post-Inquisition Spain: “It is not surprising that in the period after the expulsion the notion of “blood cleansing” appeared, where forced conversoes with a Jewish past were ‘stained’.”

This act, lead by the Catholic church, entailed the systematic torture and interrogation of suspected Jews up to the 18th century:

In the twentieth century, the discourse of pure blood especially nourishes the undemocratic right, like the Falange española

Franco brought the propagandistic discourse of Castille’s pure blood and a rigid cultural prototype into the 20th century. During and after the Civil War, large-scale concentration camps housed ex-Republican servicemen and political dissidents. Those seen as ‘un-recoverable’ were shot.

 

cat3A Catalan Independence march last November, by Barcelona’s Placa Espana.

 

In a history where race, religion, ethnicity and cultural-geographic groupings overlap with each other, we shouldn’t attempt to map Catalonia’s marginalisation onto patterns of racial and ethnic oppression. But they do offer us a glimpse into how profoundly committed the Spanish central government is to maintaining a unitary identity by using force and sanction to bring to heel all those seen to deviate. A unitary identity becomes a powerful way of exercising control over a population; a false idol of monolithic so-called Spanishness to unify a population in a time where many have staked their political and economic futures on a unified Spain. Catalonia is one of the nation’s wealthiest regions, and independence might threaten to plunge the remainder of Spain into economic chaos. In these circumstances, a tool as urgent and powerful as a sense of unified Spanishness is one worth defending at a high cost. Though it has shocked many in the international community, Spain’s move to starve Catalonia’s budget into de facto submission is by no means beyond the pale of this logic.

Plastic national identities.

That the state remains invested in heavily policing Jewish and Muslim life in Spain chimes to the same anxiety; that repressing certain groups has proved so politically and economically useful, any identity which granted them full Spanishness threatens to undermine a project of exclusion. To guard Spanishness, white Catalonians must be forcibly brought in, whilst racial and ethnic ‘Others’ are cast out. Under the PP today, the ease with which groups can be included, or excluded, from Spain’s national identity evokes the power of Spain’s historic leaders to manipulate at will the concept of Spanishness.

Last year, Spain offered a Law of Return to the many expelled Sephardic Jews, officially claiming they were a crucial component of Spanish identity. The law is designed to make the naturalising process highly expensive and complicated, despite it being a Law of Return, which many see as a way to filter out less affluent Sephardim. It is important to note that this same definition of Spanishness was not expanded to include the many Muslims expelled from the land in the 15th and 16th century.

 

Bayi Loubaris, the president of the Association for Historical Legacy of Al-Andalus, took offence at this double-standard: “The Spanish state should grant the same rights to all those who were expelled, otherwise their decision is selective, if not racist”. The rigid definitions of Spain’s identity were felt more recently in Catalonia. In Place de Jaume of Barcelona, there is a man ensangrado(bloodied) most days of the week (or to use the Catalan for bloodied, ple de sang). He stands with posters of mauled bulls, slaughtered by a matadores. Catalonia’s regional government passed a law in 2010 which banned bull-fighting in the region. But Spain’s government annulled the ban in October of last year, deeming bull fighting a “national heritage”.

 

span5A Spanish patriot in Barcelona on the 12th of October, The National Day of Spain.

 

These cultural battles become the shibboleths for grander – and altogether more violent – battles over which kinds of government have the right to make and enforce laws on the territories of Spain. What can be seen as a paranoid enforcement of a unified, centralised identity fuelled the notorious Basque separatist terrorist group, ETA, standing for “Basque Homeland and Liberty”. Between 1986 and 2010 they killed 829 people, both politicians to civilians.

Just as laws prevent history textbooks from teaching diverse understandings of the 20th century, the will to limit a pluralist understanding of Spain’s national identity can be seen in the academic field. I spoke to a recent PhD graduate, Angy Cohen, from Madrid University. She specialises in Sephardic Jewish identity, through which she explores the historically shifting identities of Spanishness. She is frustrated at a culture still hostile to deconstructing definitions of Spain’s identity, reflected through funding restrictions:

It’s interesting that Spain has some of the best historians I’ve ever seen, the level is extremely high but Spain’s national identity is blocked – so if you trying to re-define Spain’s national identity – it will be a struggle. It’s all bound up because these questions lead to the claim of certain regions of Spain for self-determination. Its a very complex question that has to do with this inability – this very long history of persecution and repression of Spain’s national identity.

Tanks in Barcelona?

Under the PP, a centralised identity enforced through multiple legal and institutional formations has become a conduit for re-articulating deeply conservative values; the heritage of Franco’s reactionary governance. Thus, it is unsurprising that the fight for independence is seen by many Catalonians as the fight for a more progressive, democratic Spain. Spain’s current constitution states that for any regional law in Catalonia to be changed, the Spanish parliament must vote. Catalonia, with a small minority of representational seats in the national government, will side-step legality to ensure a referendum goes forward this October 1. Its draft legislation is clear:

If the Spanish state effectively impedes the holding of a referendum, this law will enter into effect in a complete and immediate manner when the [regional] parliament has verified such an impediment.

Catalonian’s are far from unified in their opinion on independence. Reasons for wanting national autonomy vary widely; from the primarily economic, to those of a more cultural or historical nature as discussed above. But many Catalonia’s are uncomfortable with voting for an independence that has no clear independence plan. To anyone spectating the fallout from Brexit, this may seem hauntingly familiar.

Though Carles Puigdemont does not have the unanimous support for the illegal vote that he claims, Catalonians are largely unified in their belief that they are entitled to a vote. Despite the fact that the vote is unlikely to swing the way of independence at this stage, the very fact of the referendum re-articulates lines of division and in declaring autonomy and difference, even as it looks to re-sign up to the uneasy contract at the heart of the modern Spanish state, a detente between the unified state and its fractious regions.

If the vote goes ahead, Spanish tanks have been promised on the streets of Catalonia during the voting period. Once again, central state power has failed to fully realise itself through a monolithic cultural identity and so has resorted to the old reliables; money and guns. Catalonian independence is no guarantee of prosperity or liberty for Catalonians, many of whom would likely face just the same ethnic or religious discrimination as is handed down by governments past and present. But the simple fact of holding the referendum tests the limits of what states will do to protect their territorial integrity. A firm fist on the national wallet and tanks on the streets of Barcelona.

 

catA Catalan Independence march last November, by Barcelona’s Placa Espana.

The Clash of Barcelona’s Jewish leaders

 

Published by Jewdas

   Re-published by the Jewish Renaissance 

 

The Israeli Times was the site of a less-public conflict in the aftermath of Barcelona’s attack last week. Its pages perpetuated a time-worn pattern: In times of conflict, Jewish communities’ relations to their diaspora are challenged un-constructively by Jewish leaders.

After a van plunged into the teeming Las Ramblas, killing 16 and injuring 100, two pillars of the community clashed in their public response to the attack, amplified by the paper.

Barcelona’s Chief Rabbi Ben-Har, portended Europe’s ‘doom’ and asserted that ‘Jews are not here permanently’. The Rabbi called for Spain’s 40,000 Jews to ‘buy property in Israel’, as their home was a ‘hub of Islamist terror for all of Europe’.

After The Israel Times published the Rabbi’s statement, Victor Sorrenson, a spokesman for the Jewish community, sent a loaded email to the paper’s inbox.

‘Barcelona is not afraid, its Jews join them in this stance’. His definitive message was ‘social action’ from Barcelona’s community, not departure.

I spoke to Victor from his office in Barcelona, to find out how two community figures can have such a polarised reaction to the event, and his view on the future of the diaspora in Europe.

Victor opened by explaining that the Rabbi’s view was not ‘representative’ of the community, unfortunate considering that the newspaper had jumped to publish his response:

‘The Rabbi should not have attended the media the same day of the attack. Beyond the fact that the media may have exaggerated their position, I think it is a mistake for a religious leader to take sides that way. He has been in Barcelona for six years, the community, one hundred’

Victor expanded on the logistics of the post-attack community response, as there had been a an elected ‘crisis committee’, and Victor was appointed as the ‘spokesperson’:

‘The message was very clear: Condemn the terrorist attacks, give all our support for the authorities and participate in the social fabric of Barcelona to show our commitment to the city’.

The Rabbi’s response, siting the imperative for the community to move away from the diaspora as opposed to solidarity, is a tired motif. Such soothsaying undermine the diasporas’ efforts, and success, in re-inscribing their identity into Europe.

European leaders heaped critique on the Israeli Prime Minister, Binyamin Netanyahu, following his response after the Paris Kosher-supermarket and Copenhagen attacks last year. His message was clear: ‘Israel is waiting for you with open arms’.

Accusations of Netanyahu’s strategically-timed damning of the future of Europe rippled across the media’s international waters.

Chief Rabbi Bar-Hen, echoing the view of many vocal zionist Jewish leaders, claimed that the community in Barcelona was ‘not permanent’. Victor counter-acted this pessimism:

‘There is a growing interest in the general Catalan population in Jewish matters, an interest that we see translating into spiritual, historical and intellectual curiosity. In short, there is a vibrancy to Jewish life in Barcelona. This will be the trend for the future. I do not know anyone, either before or after the attack, to consider leaving for security reasons’

The Rabbi, ignoring Spain’s sociocultural specificity, had warned Jews not to ‘repeat the mistake of Algerian Jews, of Venezuelan Jews. Better [get out] early than late’. Outside of drawing parallels with other continents, he claimed that ‘Europe is lost’.

Victor, when this was re-sited to him, argued that: ‘Each country has a different history. To encompass all on the same label “Europe”, is reductionistic and shows an ignorance of the reality that is being lived politically’.

Despite its pervasive anti-semitism, Spain has not had a violent attack against Jews for years, unlike France. Victor suggests that in the face of new terror threats rising in Spain, the Jewish community feels supported:

‘What I can say is that our relationship with the security forces is excellent. We work with them on a regular basis, since as in so many other places, Jewish spaces had been targeted before the terrorist threat.’

The disregarding of Barcelona’s place-specific security-levels forms part of a mind set that undermines diasporic identity by homogenising it within Europe. The diasporas’ sociocultural idiosyncrasies are a distraction to Israel, seen as the only true Jewish homeland.

The Rabbi seemed impervious to the irony that thousands of Israeli’s had been trying to pass Spain’s Law of Return of 2015. If an applicant can prove their ancestor’s Sephardic origins they can be nationalised as Spanish. A writer from Haaretz evokes the reaction in Israel:

‘Normal countries, with normal people, don’t go crazy just because an economically-challenged country offered them citizenship. But Israel did’

The Chaplin-esque image of these paradoxical movements sites the insecurity of Jewish life, where is safe? Israel certainly isn’t.

However, expanding on the future of the diaspora within Europe as a whole, Victor has a restless energy:

‘One of the projects I coordinate is the European Days of Jewish Culture, where 324 cities from all over Europe participated simultaneously last year. I think it is representative that Judaism in Europe goes beyond anti-Semitism and the Holocaust.

We Jews are an active part of European society, we are not a museum object.’

 

IMG_2390

A light shines on a hole marking where the Mezuzah stood 500 years ago in Barcelona’s Gothic quarter, until the Inquisition sent Spain’s Sephardim from Cairo to Amsterdam. Since the late 19th century, Sephardim have returned to re-build their identity into Sepharad

 

 

Victor’s vision for the role of the diaspora within Europe is one of social activism and building more presence for Jews in public spaces.

He co-runs the Berlin-born initiative Salaam-Shalom in Barcelona, organising workshops between the cities’ Jews and Muslims. Victor also founded Mozaika, a journal publishing academic papers and pioneering archival research on Jewish history and culture in Catalonia.

What one sees as an offering of support, others see as a strategically placed call to Israel when a community is vulnerable. The reconstruction of the diaspora’s identity into post-Shoah Europe is advanced by their show of solidarity in events such as the Barcelona attacks. Such responses ensure a reciprocation from their neighbours in the likely event of their own targeting.

Culture Cuts: Sri Lankan Tamils

Culture Cuts: Sri Lankan Tamils

 

*All names have been changed, and photos obscured, to secure the subjects’ anonymity. There are no facial photos of the interviewees. Place names and specific information are included to the degree that the interviewee was comfortable with..

.

Published by Novara Media

.

“I want to show you a cemetery”, an unexpected endnote to an interview about teaching the Tamil language in the borough of Newham. Lashani pushes open the door of a disused room, three flights up. Light enters from a window yawning over a communal space, encased by a block of houses. Our viewpoint is through the back of the London Tamil Sangam of which Lashani is the head teacher.

“Its a disused Jewish cemetery from before the 2nd world war, you can only see it from these houses,” Lashani tells me. She points to the dignified epitaphs and faded Hebrew script. The cemetery’s gates have been closed to the public since 2003, after 386 of its tombstones were defaced. Their crumbling facades recall the bombs that swept across London.   

.

.

finf

.            The Sangam center, founded in 1936, is one of the oldest Tamil organisations in London.

.

The centre teaches the Tamil language to second-generation Sri Lankan Tamil refugees, many of which are Newham residents. A small proportion of Lashini’s student’s parents came to the UK during the course of Sri Lanka’s 26 year civil war. The economic reasons for immigration in the 70’s became the seeking of asylum in the 80’s following the country’s growing instability.

Today, there are close to 200,000 Sri Lankan Tamils in England, with the majority living in London.

Although Sri Lankan Tamils have found employment in financial and medical fields since the 70s, many refugee and asylum seekers from Sri Lanka seek emotional and practical support from community centres. Offering financial advice, legal aid, free meals, English lessons and counselling, these centres are fuelled by donations, volunteers and council grant schemes.

However, councils across London are drastically reducing their funding to the centres that support this diasporic group, despite growing demands for their services under the last five years of the Conservative’s austerity measures. In London’s most deprived communities, social care has fallen by £65 per head since 2010, while charities have lost over £3.8 bn from Government funding over the last decade.

Before travelling to Newham to find out about how local government cuts are affecting London’s Tamil community, I went to Murugan Temple in Highgate to learn about Sri Lanka’s past.

26 Years of Civil War

Bali sighs. This conversation is at best recycled. New revelations are not unearthed. He treads with expert feet along the timeline of Sri Lanka’s past violence. He is a Tamil, and left Sri Lanka in 1976 following the country’s civil unrest.

Nearing his 80’s, he tends to circumvent political discussion, volunteering every weekend at Highgate’s Murugan Temple. “As long as your heart is clear you can come to this temple. We ingrain no politics – God can punish those who are bad, that is my philosophy.”

We walk along the 12 inward facing shrines of the temple’s body. Worshipers perform parikrama: making circles around the statues of Gods. “We bought the deities over from Southern India”, he whispers, not to disturb the Sanskrit chants emerging from the temple’s inner sanctum. He ushers me to the ticket office, our conversation interrupted when he gives me a placard displaying the Tamil alphabet. 

.

.

tamilalphabet

The Tamil language is spoken from Southern India to Malaysia, and by Tamil diasporic communities across the globe. Online forums contest whether the language is older than Sanskrit.

.

.

In 1948, Britain’s colonial rule of Sri Lanka ended. During their regime, ethnic tensions between the Sinhalese and Tamil population   emerged, exacerbated by Britain’s unfair advantaging of the Tamil minority. The Sinhalese, mainly Buddhist and Sinhala speaking, make up roughly 75% of Sri Lanka’s population, while the Tamils, mainly Hindu and Tamil speaking, make up just under 12%.

“The Tamils were in the top posts during Britain’s rule. When the Sinhalese came into power following Independence, they wanted to stop the Tamils from going to university”, explains Bali.

Over the course of the following few decades, a series of reforms were implemented by the Sinhalese to disadvantage the Tamils, beginning with education. “The Tamil’s entrance marks were made higher than theirs, making it very difficult for them to get into higher education”. In 1956, Sinhalese was made the country’s only official language.

After nearly three decades of Tamil oppression under Sinhalese rule, 1976 saw the formation of the Tamil Tigers. Prabakaran, who led and founded the military group, became the unfiltered microphone that amplified thousands of disillusioned Tamil voices. The group’s main objective was to secure a separatist state for the Tamils, within Sri Lanka’s borders.

A few months following the Tiger’s formation, The Tamil United Liberation Front, a Pro-Tamil rights parties, entered their first general election. Bali started to cry as he told me about the democratic party, holding its biography. With 70% of the electorate being Sinhalese, the party stood little chance of instigating reforms.

With the chances of peaceful political reform for the Tamils minimal, the Tigers became the vanguards of Independence. They attacked both Sinhalese and Tamils to secure this title. Freedom fighters quickly morphed into terrorists on the international podium.

“They slipped a letter warning that they would kill my father if he remained in Northern Sri Lanka in 1985. He was a District Chairman for the government. While he was sleeping, they came and shot him in the head. They didn’t have a plan, they just shot”.

.

.

  censorimage2

.Hindu Priests are traditionally Brahmins, the highest caste within the Hindu System. The Tamil Tigers fought to dissolve the caste system, advocating for an egalitarian and Communistic mode of governance.

.

censortest

.The main duty of the Pujari is to act as an intermediate between the worshiper and God. They traditionally wear a Janaeu, or white thread around the body. The knot symbolises the priests’ pledge to to be pious.

.

The Tigers’ Separatist nation was gradually secured in the North and East of the country, with its own functioning government, bank and television station.

The perfecting of the suicide bomber. Massacres of Sinhalese Civilians. The utilisation of child soldiers. The murder of Tamil defectors. It was not easy for the Tiger’s to retain the core ideals of their manifesto while preventing the government’s forces from defeating their de facto state.

Sri Lanka’s majority-Sinhalese military were guilty of numerous human right’s abuses during their combat with the Tigers. Notorious for their high levels of sexual assault of woman civilians and Tiger fighters, this problem has far from disappeared. During the war, thousands of Tamil civilians disappeared. White vans would remove suspected Tiger sympathisers to faceless detention centres.

The civil war clawed itself into the 21st century. The fighting picked up speed, and international recognition, until its culmination in 2009. In the last year of fighting, the accusatory fingers of foreign governments pointed at Rajapaksa, Sri Lanka’s former president:

During the defeat of the Tamil Tiger’s in 2009, thousands of Tamil civilians were shelled in “safe zones”. These zones had been allocated by the Sri Lankan government in the final phase of the war. The casualties proliferated on both sides. Up to 20,000 Sinhalese and Tamils were killed in the last 4 months of combat.

Ethnic cleansing! Genocide! Protests in Parliament Square surged. Calls for foreign intervention were unanswered. The final surrender of the Tigers came a day before Prabakaran’s body was found floating in mangroves.

Today, Sri Lanka’s recovery from the war is slow. Improvements of Tamil rights under the new president Sirisena lack momentum. Military camps and detentions centres are still rooted on Northern Sri Lanka’s soil. War crime allegations have not been assessed by an external judiciary. The newly elected army chief lead a key division of the military during the last two months of the war.

.

.

  shrine3

The Temple’s priests, or pujaris, conduct the daily puja, a Sanskrit word for worship. There are up to 16 main steps in the worship, from washing the deity’s feet to offering them a seat.

.

Bali traces invisible lines over his open palm. At the end of our conversation, he returns to the 80s:

“They burnt our library in Jaffna in 1981. There were Tamil scriptures, manuscripts. They were written on Palmera leaves – they are all gone..the whole collection was kept in the library”. Jaffna library was burnt during civilian riots. A similar dent was felt in the cultural archives of Mao’s China and Nazi Germany – the burning of books always ignites a greater fire.

.

.

The Tamil Language – Culture Cuts

.

.

Bali’s regret of the offensive against Tamil cultural artefacts, reverberates in Selvan’s concerns about the state of the Tamil culture under the current Sri Lankan government. I met Selvan, a Tamil refugee of the 80’s, in a Hare Krishna temple in East Croyden.

He promotes the teaching of the Tamil language in London, fuelled through his fears of its increasingly marginalised status in Sri Lanka. FreedomHouse reports that ‘the status of Sinhala as the official language puts Tamils and other non-Sinhala speakers at a disadvantage’.

Sinhala is spoken predominantly in the South, the region with the most economic growth and governmental departments, while the North, with high levels of poverty and unemployment, is majority Tamil speaking.

In the North today, efforts to improve an economy failing through the infrastructural damages of the war are minimal. Sirisena’s lack of initiative is felt by Selvan: The school of his Tamil-majority village was bombed 7 years ago. Today, the rubble has been cleared, but there are no efforts to reconstruct the building.

.

.

selvans-school

After negotiating with locals MPs and gaining approval from the region’s military commander, Selvan’s charity, Sinnathurai Children Foundation was registered. We built the old school again and now it’s an afternoon school for children. When it rains they are living in huts still!” (pictured above).

.

.

Selvan sees London’s community centres as crucial for fostering Tamil culture outside of Sri Lanka’s borders. “We are distributed everywhere now, all over the world. We have to show our children what our culture is, our religion – to teach them the language…A lot of things have been lost but even if we move to another country we still have our culture”.

However, Lashani, from the London Tamil Sangam, has had to start charging a small fee for lessons following local government cuts.

Lashani prepares her students for the Tamil language GCSE, enabling many 2nd generation refugees to speak to family members in Sri Lankan that do not speak English.

.

.

  censorfinalnovara

The Sangam centre’s library houses current Sri Lankan and Southern Indian Tamil newspapers, as well as poems originating from 300 BCE.

.

.

“Many of the elder generation are lonely and can only speak Tamil here,” Lashani explains. “People are suffering in silence.. I lost my husband a couple of months ago..I can share my sorrow with people, and speak about them in my own language”. With a further £20m cuts this year to resources teaching the English language, the center works to prevent language barriers from isolating refugees.

The cuts faced by the Sangam center are marginal in comparison to the nearby Upton and Hartley centres. Following a withdrawal of fundings from NewHam’s shrinking grant scheme, both centres closed last year. The charities hosted lessons in Hindu culture, English classes and events for the elderly.

Newham council, despite being the 6 most deprived area in England, will receive £284 less for every home in the borough as of 2017, while Richmond, a substantially wealthier area, will have its grants cuts by just £57 per home.

The effects of these cuts reverberate in North London, with New Barnet’s Sangam Centre’s facing depleting council funds, a charity providing advice to Sri Lankan Tamil women. With charity grants predicted to have disappeared by the next 4 years, this decline in funding can only sharpen.

.

.

                 London’s Community spaces – Frontiers to Censorship

.

.

“The Tigers are freedom fighters”, Ravi asserts. ‘Ravi’, a fake name, agreed to talk to me after I assured him that the interview would be anonymous. Community spaces encourage the sharing of sorrow, the dispersion of loneliness. They also become places where frustration can be shared without fear of censorship.

Ravi taps his hand on his knee. His gold chains vibrate with the movement. The emblems are obscured as they disappear into his white t-shirt. We sit on a soft carpet in a temple in Wembley. He is a second-generation refugee. “I know nothing, only what my Mum tells me”. His proviso dissolves as we begin talking about censorship in Sri Lanka.

“I have friends here with bullet wounds, I can give you their number”. The offer was never followed up. What’s in it for him? To publicly discuss or protest for Tamil rights in London could place yourself on Sri Lanka’s watch list:

Under Sri Lanka’s Prevention of Terrorism Act, suspected Tiger sympathisers are detained on return to the capital’s airport. This can result in interrogation and torture without trial.

“If you put my name or my picture in a magazine, then I can’t go back to Sri Lanka..I protested in 2009 during the civil war, there were photos of me in Parliament Square – there’s a 50/50 chance I’ll be caught if I went back”.

.

.

cencorship

“It is not a catch-penny book, with life like that of a mushroom”. An excerpt from the Preface of the Bhavitha Gita, the main text of the Hindu and Hare Krishna faith.

.

.

The Home Offices August Report on Sri Lanka disclosed that family members have been questioned in Sri Lanka, following the participation of relatives in anti-government protests abroad.

Ravi has family in Sri Lanka. For many in the same position, it is fear for their protection that dictates how politically active they are in their places of asylum, meaning community centres and temples often become substitutions for street protests.

Wembley’s Hindu temples will have to shoulder increasing council tax following Brent’s growing cuts, despite the fact that many of them relieve the pressure of food banks by providing free meals on a daily basis. The council recognises this financial reality as a pattern spanning across the UK’s borroughs: ‘We are not alone, as around 86 per cent of councils are planning to increase council tax’, their website states.

.

.

The UK’s Closing Borders

.

.

Beyond the shrinking resources that help the Sri Lankan’s who have been granted asylum in the UK, it is also the routes for potential refugees that are threatened under the UK’s tightening borders.

Newham’s Tamil Welfare Association has been supporting asylum seekers coming to the UK from Sri Lanka since 1985. The center is a 10 minute walk from the Sangam Tamil Language School. Along High Street North, connecting the two centres, the walk of Hindus to their daily puja (worship) is soundtracked by the sound of saluhs (prayers) in the borough’s local mosques. 

.

.

newtemple

.

.

The centre’s building is small, its outreach extensive: Asylum seekers with no legal representation and stuck in detention centres while their claim is reviewed, or refugees seeking legal advice, often call Pradeep, one of the founders.

A woman in her 50’s cries in the centre’s waiting room, she is handed a letter by one of the volunteers. I question whether I should be there, taking up an hour of Pradeep’s time. The center has about 30 walk-ins a day. During our interview, he would run to retrieve a yellow legal file and deposit it on the desk of his colleagues, talking on the phone in Tamil.

The UK’s toughening asylum seeking process highlights the importance of the center. Since 2005, the majority of refugees are granted access to the UK for only 5 years, while over a half of asylum seekers are detained during their application review.

Pradeep knows the UK’s border control process intimately – he was part of the surge of Tamil refugees seeking asylum in England in the 1980’s during the build-up to the civil war.

He’s laughing. Pradeep’s response to my question of whether he thought conditions for asylum seekers had improved significantly since his arrival, which he recounts to me:

“I left on my own. Afterwards my family came here, one by one. Actually my father was shot by the Sinhalese and he survived. When I arrived here, I was detained with 58 other Tamils in the Ashford Remand center in 1985, but we started to fight. With the help of Jeremy Corbyn, the detainees were released. We initially formed this organisation as a self-help group, with a group of refugees putting money in”.

Pradeep is not overawed with Jacques Audiard’s recent film Dheepan, depicting the struggles of a Tamil refugee following his arrival in Europe. The film ends with an angelic choir. They infuse a shot of Dheepan, the protagonist, as a black-cab driver parking in his suburban driveway.

He see’s the blockbuster as symptomatic of a lack of understanding surrounding the reality facing many refugees on arrival to their places of asylum. Perhaps the recent Ken Loach film I am Daniel Blake, with its benefit freezes and food banks, is a more accurate depiction of life following the granting of refugee status.

The UK’s shrinking support for incoming asylum seekers and refugees, renders the future of Pradeep’s charity unstable. Despite the centre’s popularity, it increasingly relies on volunteers, and donations from local residents.

After its near collapse in 1994 following a withdrawal of government funding, its continuation is testament to the associations’s importance in alleviating the suffering of the Sri Lankan Tamil refugee, and asylum seekers, that reach out to it from across the UK. However, Pradeep, remains concerned for his centre’s future:

“There is bad media coverage of the situation and funders are withdrawing. Policy wise the government is not giving grants for asylum seekers.. the general public is a bit scared of refugees. It’s very hard to run a refugee charity..normal charities don’t face hatred”.

.

.

smallnahibpraying

.

.

Refugee centres provided advice to Sri Lankan Tamils in South-East London are also facing cuts. An employee from Lewisham’s Refugee and Migrant Network reports that ‘our charity has had to absorb the clients affected by centres that have closed down due to funding cuts’.

These centres, supporting London’s multiple diasporic communities, have experienced increasing demand: the Red Cross reports that over 3,000 asylum seekers have been living in ‘destitution’ this year.

After an asylum seeker is granted refugee status, the government grants them 28 days before their financial support is cut, despite the fact that finding a job often extends far beyond a month. As a direct result of this law, the Red Cross measured a 10% rise in refugees seeking food parcels or emergency cash from them since 2015.

  

Autumn Statement

.

.

In 2013, David Cameron broke official protocol by visiting a camp for displaced Tamils in Northern Sri Lanka. His cameo appearance intending to draw attention to Sri Lanka’s lack of investigation into alleged war crimes. Cameron left, the news moved on but the cutting of resources that support Sri Lankan refugees in the UK continued.

Cameron’s stunt echoes Theresa May’s first series of speeches as Prime Minister, broadcasting solidarity with the working families of England. Encouraging words, often unsubstantiated.

Change, however, is forthcoming in the Home Office. As of 2016, only 14 out of 147 asylum applications were accepted from Sri Lanka. This is a distinct fall from 2015’s 45% acceptance rate of appeals.

The decrease in asylum granting is not so much a reaction to some of the ‘improvements’ marked in Sri Lanka, but to the influx of refugees to European and UK borders. With the UK gaining more control over its borders in the wake of Brexit, this decrease is set to continue.

The futures’ of Sri Lankan Tamils with rejected asylum applications are unstable – they are sent back to a country they initially left over concerns for their safety. Jasmine Pilbrow, a student who refused to sit down on a flight instrumental in the deportation of a Sri Lankan Tamil in Melbourne last year, draws media attention to a process seldom reported on.

The ongoing problems in Sri Lanka should make the obstacles faced by Tamils refugees harder to ignore: the censors on freedom of speech, the difficulty of Tamils resettling in the North following their removal during the war and the threat of torture and detention are proving slow to improve.

Once asylum seekers arrive to the UK’s borders, the support of these community centres are crucial. Many asylum seekers’ visa applications are stretched from months to years, with the UK having the longest wait for a work permit in Europe. With social welfare continuously decreasing, the practical and emotional support of these centres for Sri Lankan Tamil Refugees grow in importance.

The livelihoods of these centres will be measured in Phillip Hammond’s upcoming autumn statement. As it stands, the UK’s austerity measures are set to continue into the 2020s, although Hammond has hinted at a divergence from Osborne’s long-term budget. However, the new Chancellor’s recent assurance that ‘we remain committed to fiscal discipline’ renders any substantial reversal of the Conservative’s ongoing cuts doubtful.

Weddings

.

.

.

nick5

.

.

.

secondwed13

.

.

.

secondwed17

.

.

.

wed4

.

.

.

wed7

.

.

.

wed8

.

.

.

wed9

.

.

.

wed10

.

.

.

wed11

.

.

.

wed12

.

.

.

wed25

.

.

.

 

wedlightii

.

.

.

 

weds27

.

.

.

.

.

.

Kerala

 

.

.

.

Aisha, 20

Janmashtami (Hare Krishna’s Birthday)

.

.

aisha

.

.

Breaking earthen pots filled with curd to celebrate the legend of Krishna, the child-god, from stealing butter. Locals hang their butter in pots from the ceiling to ward against the deities theft. 

.

.

..new.

.

..

newIIII.

.

.news.

.

.

water

.

.

.stick 1

.

.

.

templeII

.

.

temple

.

.

.

Shoba, 17

Varkala beach .

 

girlI.

.

.motorII

.

.

.

tea

.

.

.

Held every month at Sivananda Ashram, thousands of locals travel from the surrounding area to this health camp – gaining a free consultation and meal and leaving with a bag of Ayurvedic medicine. The Ashram is volunteer run and not profit driven, all of its proceeds go towards funding the registered medical charity.

 

.

..

.queue copy

 

.

pensive.

.

.handII.

.

.

hand.

.

.friendsII.

.

.friendsI.

.

.

.

 

Elephant Rehabilitation Center,

Neyyar Dam 

.

 

.ele.

.

Chamudeswery Temple,

Nedumangad

.

A Hindu archaka who conducts ritual worship and the elephant he is sculpting 

.

elephant+..

 

.priestess1

.

.

..fatherandson.

.

.templeII.

.

..

.

.

 

.

.

.

Brainchild Festival Performers

.

.

.

The Performers of  BrainChild Festival 2016

(official festival photographer – 8th-10th July)

Click here to see the Brainchildren and here to see my Utopias series

.

.

.

.

.

Steeze Cafe

Jerkcurb

.

.

.

.

.

Jerkcurb - Steeze (8th) 4

.

.

.

.

Jerkcurb - Steeze (8th) 5

.

.

.

.

Jerkcurb - Steeze (8th) 6

.

.

.

Space Jam

.

m.

Space Jam - Steez (8th) 3

.

.

.

.

Space Jam - Steez (8th) 5

.

.

.

.

Ezra Collective - Steeze (9th) 2

.

.

.

The Audioters

.

.

The Audioters - Steez (9th) 2

.

.

.

.

The Audioters - Steez (9th) 4

.

.

.

.

The Audioters - Steez (9th) 5

.

.

.

.

MVC - Steeze (10th) 1

.

.

.

.

Steeze - performer ? - (10th) 5.

.

.

.

.

Steeze - performer ? - (10th) 2

.

.

.

.

Steeze - performer ? - (10th) 6

.

.

.

SumoChief

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  1

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  2

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  4

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  5

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  6

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  7

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  8

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  9

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  10

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  11

.

.

.

.

SumoChief - Steeze (10th)  12

.

.

.

.

Brain Stage

Nerija

.

Nerija - Steeze (10th) 9.

.

.

.

.

Nerija - Steeze (10th) 1

.

.

.

.

Nerija - Steeze (10th) 4.

.

.

.

.

Nerija - Steeze (10th) 8

.

.

.

Babeheaven

.

.

Babe Heaven - Brain Stage (8th) 2

.

.

.

.

Babe Heaven - Brain Stage (8th) 4

.

.

.

.

Babe Heaven - Brain Stage (8th) 10

.

.

.

.

Babe Heaven - Brain Stage (8th) 11

.

.

.

Huw Bennett Quintet 

.

.

Huw Bennett Quintet - Brain Stage (8th) 1

.

.

.

.

Huw Bennett Quintet - Brain Stage (8th) 2

.

.

.

.

Huw Bennett Quintet - Brain Stage (8th) 6

.

.

.

Alfa Mist & Barney Artist

.

.

Alfa Mist & Barney Artist- Brain stage (9th) 2

.

.

.

.

Alfa Mist & Barney Artist- Brain stage (9th) 4

.

..

Alice Phoebe Lou

.

.

Alice Phoebe Lou - Brain Stage (9th) 1

.

.

.

.

Alice Phoebe Lou - Brain Stage (9th) 2

.

.

.

.

Alice Phoebe Lou - Brain Stage (9th) 6

.

.

.

.

Alice Phoebe Lou - Brain Stage (9th) 9

.

.

.

.

Alice Phoebe Lou - Brain Stage (9th) 12

.

.

.

.

Alice Phoebe Lou - Brain Stage (9th) 13

.

.

.

.

Alice Phoebe Lou - Brain Stage (9th) 14

.

.

King Nommo

.

.

King Nommo - Brain Stage (9th) 2

.

.

Jelani Blackman Music

..

Jelani Blackman Music - Brain Stage (10th) 2

.

.

.

.

Jelani Blackman Music - Brain Stage (10th) 6

.

.

.

.

Jelani Blackman Music - Brain Stage (10th) 8

.

.

.

.

Jelani Blackman Music - Brain Stage (10th) 10

.

.

.

.

Jelani Blackman Music - Brain Stage (10th) 13

.

.

Junk Son 

.

Junk Son - Brain Stage (10th) 1

.

.

.

.

Junk Son - Brain Stage (10th) 2

.

.

United Vibrations

..

United Vibrations - Brain Stage (10th) 2

.

.

.

The Shack

.

.

Contours 

.

.

Contours - The Shack (8th) 1

.

.

.

.

Contours - The Shack (8th) 2

.

.

.

.

dj1

.

.

The Dead of Night in the Middle of Nowhere 

..

.

The Dead of Night in the Middle of Nowhere - The Woods (9th) 1

.

.

.

.

The Dead of Night in the Middle of Nowhere - The Woods (9th) 4

.

.

.

.

The Dead of Night in the Middle of Nowhere - The Woods (9th) 8

.

.

.

.

The Dead of Night in the Middle of Nowhere - The Woods (9th) 9

.

.

.

.

The Dead of Night in the Middle of Nowhere - The Woods (9th) 11

.

.

.

.

The Dead of Night in the Middle of Nowhere - The Woods (9th) 12

.

.

.

The Cinema

.

The Beanfield by Breech Theatre

.

.

The Beanfield by Breech Theatre - the Cinema (8th) 1

.

.

.

Creamer Mag – Zine Making Workshop

.

.

Creamer Mag - Zine Making Workshop - The Cinema (10th) 1

.

.

.

.

Creamer Mag - Zine Making Workshop - The Cinema (10th) 2

.

.

.

.

Creamer Mag - Zine Making Workshop - The Cinema (10th) 3

.

.

.

.

Brainchild(ren)

Details & Portraits of 2016 BrainChild Festival 2016

(official festival photographer – 8th-10th July)

Click here to see the Performers and here to see Utopia series

.

.

.

.

cam1

.

.

.

.

beer

.

.

.

.

.blursleepyexperiment

.

.

.

.

dance2

.

.

.

.

dance4

.

.

.

.

dancer

.

.

.

.

dancing

.

.

.

.

dancing3

.

.

.

.

experimentsleep

.

.

.

.

fairy

.

.

.

.

feet1

.

.

.

.

fire

.

.

.

.

friends1 copy

.

.

.

.

froggies

.

.

.

.

glitter copy

.

.

.

.

glitter3

.

.

.

.

hands copy.jpg

.

.

.

.

magic4

.

.

.

.

molly copy

.

.

.

.

molly

.

.

.

.

netting

.

.

.

.

orange1

.

.

.

.

.

pom

.

.

.

.

.

pom4

.

.

.

.

rachel

.

.

.

.

sailor

.

.

.

.

smiley2

.

.

.

.

steeze

.

.

.

.

strongbow

.

.

.

.

.

watchers3